By Isa Jones
By Mary Willson
By Brian Turk
By Drew AIles
By Taylor Boylston
By Bree Davies
By Emerald O'Brien
At appearances June 5 at the Fillmore Auditorium and June 7 at McNichols Arena, Dylan repaid this loyalty. The concept behind his current tour, which pairs him with fellow tunesmith Paul Simon, is a bad idea, as should have been obvious from the start: When the average person thinks of angelic harmonies à la Art Garfunkel, they don't think of Bob Dylan. Still, Dylan's own music was effortless and approachable, and if too much of it dated from his glory days, his trademark restlessness gave it a fresh jolt. In two separate reviews, a Rocky Mountain News reviewer stated that Dylan spent much of his time in the spotlight grinning, which most certainly was not the case: Anyone who bothered to get close to the stage at the Fillmore (or could afford to do so at McNichols) saw that he's developed a Humphrey Bogart-like facial tic that causes him to intermittently lift his upper lip, thereby baring his teeth in a semi-wince. But his mincing, tentative dance steps and silly poses, executed with the supreme self-consciousness of a shy adolescent checking himself out in a mirror, indicated that he's not ready for the grave quite yet.
The Fillmore set began on a laconically witty note--a cover of "Friend of the Devil" that slyly acknowledged the Grateful Dead's connection to the room--before rolling into a "Mr. Tambourine Man" with a vocal melody completely different from the one he originally wrote. On one level, this tack seemed merely eccentric: It was as if Dylan had decided to sing old words to a freshly penned tune because it was easier than coming up with new ones. But when he performed the same tune at McNichols using yet another melody line, it became clear that he was defending against boredom (the tune is approximately 35 years old) even as he was screwing with the audience's perceptions. At most concerts, audiences cheer familiar riffs or notes at the beginning of songs; at a Dylan show, the crowd often has to wait for the lyric--which is probably just the way Bob likes it.
Not every change was an improvement: A reimagined "Blowin' in the Wind" at the Fillmore felt forced. But the delicate, pedal-steel-flavored versions of "Just Like a Woman" (Fillmore) and "A Simple Twist of Fate" (McNichols) were unexpectedly gorgeous, and the decision to turn "Highway 61 Revisited" (both nights) and "Maggie's Farm" (Fillmore) into ZZ Top-friendly chooglers made a certain kind of sense. Hiring hot-shit guitarist Charlie Sexton to play in the band yet not letting him play lead on most songs didn't, but that's our Bob.
By contrast, the Dylan who invited Simon to join him toward the end of his last encore at the Fillmore and McNichols was almost unrecognizable--diffident, uncertain, polite to a fault. While Dylan is undisciplined by nature, relying on spontaneity to juice him along, Simon is a buttoned-down control freak who does everything he can to keep surprises at bay. On both evenings, Simon wore the same uniform: a standard-issue insecure-balding-man's cap, a cotton windbreaker, and a plain T-shirt neatly tucked into a belted pair of tidy jeans. In other words, he resembled a wealthy executive whose attempt to dress down made him look more uptight than ever, and Dylan was unable to loosen him up. On the surface, their reworking of "The Sounds of Silence" had a reason for being: The tune became a hit only after the late producer Tom Wilson, who'd worked on some of Dylan's early electric recordings, grafted an electric guitar and a rock rhythm section onto it. But for this tour, the song's already modest tempo was slowed down to a funereal pace, with Simon crooning like a student trying not to piss off the librarian and Dylan doing little more than speaking the words in time. Worse was a medley of "I Walk the Line" and "Blue Moon of Kentucky," two potentially raucous classics that they treated as if they were thin-shelled eggs, and the Fillmore take of "Forever Young," which undercut the message with a performance more decrepit than Strom Thurmond.
Simon's turn at McNichols was equally tedious: In the midst of "Slip Slidin' Away," my wife, who accompanied me, slipped and slid straight into the land of nod, and she might still be there had I not awakened her. Rumor has it that the catastrophe that was The Capeman, Simon's flop Broadway show, has left him feeling insecure, and he showed it by kicking things off with "Bridge Over Troubled Water" and trotting out warhorses like "Mrs. Robinson." But when he tried to force-feed the throng "Further to Fly," from the yawn-worthy The Rhythm of the Saints, and a couple of Capeman numbers, the patrons responded by falling into their seats more quickly than if they'd just been infected with the Andromeda Strain.