By Alan Scherstuhl
By Michael Atkinson
By Stephanie Zacharek
By Stephanie Zacharek
By Abby Garnett
By Amy Nicholson
By Alan Scherstuhl
By Inkoo Kang
Like Truffaut before him, writer/director Moll says his favorite filmmaker is Alfred Hitchcock, and that giant's mark is evident -- in oblique ways -- on this twisted tale about a magnetic stranger who attaches himself to a bourgeois couple trying to cope with the mundane demands of parenthood. Moll has studied Hitchcock's submerged wit, elegant camera movements and gift for surprise, and subtle homages to all three show up here. So do Moll's affection for the pop frights of Stephen King (Harry is subtly flavored by both The Shining and Misery) and, if I don't miss my guess, his close reading of Joseph Conrad, in whose masterworks the moral crisis is always invading the double life. That said, let's also say that this is a highly original film blessed with fetching complications all its own and some hair-raising turns of plot.
When first we see the unsuspecting husband and wife, Michel and Claire (Laurent Lucas and Mathilde Seigner), they are plodding through a hellish summer vacation with three bickering children in the back seat of the car and no air conditioning up front. Their nerves are frazzled, and their marriage is clearly on hold. When the family stops for gas, Michel goes to the men's room and finds himself in casual conversation with a smiling, unruffled fellow traveler named Harry (Sergi López). As it happens, the two were once schoolmates. Michel barely remembers that fact, but to the inquisitive Harry it seems awfully important, and upon that Moll constructs a world of trouble and intrigue. It begins with a drink at the couple's ramshackle summer house and ends at the bottom of an abandoned well.
The trouble with Harry? Well, it wouldn't do to reveal too much, but as this handsome charmer burrows ever deeper into the lives of Michel and Claire, we pick up some strange clues. First, the guy is well-off, as evidenced by his Mercedes-Benz roadster, his ease with cash and his pneumatic bimbo (Sophie Guillemin), known to the world as "Prune." Second, there is no apparent filter between Harry's desires and his willingness to act on them, regardless of consequence. Third, he has an unnatural fixation on a poem Michel scribbled back in grammar school. Fourth, he eats raw eggs after every orgasm -- the kind of detail that proves, despite all evidence to the contrary, that la cinéma Français still lives and breathes.
In the mood for a cold-blooded murder or two? How about a meditation on the self-absorption of the artist? Or on the function of muses? Interested in dreams about monkeys that turn into short stories? Your man Dominik Moll is happy to oblige.
As you've probably sensed by now, With a Friend Like Harry may not really be about Harry at all. While Moll and his talented cast (especially the creepy and captivating López) spin an emotional web around us, we can't escape the notion that, in his insistent new friend, Michel has discovered his other, darker self -- just as Marlow found his demon in Kurtz upriver. In Freudian terms, Michel is all uptight superego, Harry sheer, unfettered id. Seen another way, Michel's dutiful Dr. Jekyll toils in the lab, Harry's Mr. Hyde wreaks havoc on the midnight streets.
Come to think of it, Professor Klump would grasp the whole thing in a millisecond. Including the business about how very, very badly Harry wants Michel to resume his writing career (shades of Kathy Bates), and how close Michel comes to turning into Jack Nicholson as the erstwhile caretaker of the Overlook Hotel. Suffice it to say that in this heady, wonderfully entertaining drama of personality conflict and disturbed yearning, there's as much going on in the high-intellect department as on the homicidal-mayhem front -- and that's always a good thing for audiences who've long since wearied of mere bloodletting. Nightmare on Elm Street this ain't.
Meanwhile, don't let on to the French culture police, but the creator of this taut and satisfying thriller is actually a German who studied at the City University of New York before matriculating in Paris. So while Harry seems thoroughly French in mood and manner, Moll's pedigree turns out to be delectably international. So much the better -- onion-soup purists be damned.
Join My Voice Nation for free stuff, film info & more!