By Antonio Valenzuela
By Alan Scherstuhl
By Alan Scherstuhl
By Stephanie Zacharek
By Michael Atkinson
By Chris Packham
By Kevin Dilmore
By Amy Nicholson
Emerging from Till Human Voices Wake Us, it was easy to overhear some male viewers striving adamantly to put the film's metaphysical themes in their place -- to explain them away, as it were. This is a shame. The source of the story's mystique is fairly simple and may be obvious to many, but to attempt to straighten out the project's purposeful obscurity is to miss its whole point.
Our focus is Sam (Guy Pearce), a stone-faced, Vandyke-bearded psychologist who returns to his small town in Victoria, Australia, to bury his father. En route via train, he encounters a mysterious woman named Ruby (Helena Bonham Carter), who suddenly vanishes. Once he's arrived at the site of his childhood, Sam steadfastly attends to domestic and funereal business, during which writer-director Michael Petroni intercuts flashbacks of Sam's younger self (astutely portrayed by newcomer Lindley Joyner). Gradually, the slick headshrinker emerges as his own case study.
Petroni, best known for adapting for the screen last year's Queen of the Damned and Dangerous Lives of Altar Boys, proves himself an instinctive and sensuous filmmaker. He favors atmosphere above action, lingering on extreme close-ups of poignant expressions or tiny details, such as young Sam's widower father (Peter Curtin) capturing the likeness of a live Christmas beetle in pen and ink and revealing volumes by explaining that his art is just "to pass the time." This pacing may gnaw like a starved bandicoot at the patience of most moviegoers, but if a darkly dreamy, vaguely "mid-century" antipodal experience appeals, you'll be well served here.
As the elegant portraiture of Sam's life expands, we come to understand his emotional detachment. All clues lead back to the local river, where he and his best friend and budding romantic interest, Silvy (Brooke Harman, also superb), languidly savor by day and night the reflections on the water, including their own. Much as in the early work of fellow Aussie John Duigan (The Year My Voice Broke, Flirting), there's magical realism afoot amid the promise of a first romance.
The thing is, despite Sam's fond memories (and an "old" sepia photo that looks, unfortunately, freshly printed), Silvy is long gone. Instead, he's got this strange Ruby woman in his face again as she falls -- or jumps -- into the same river on a stormy night. There's mud; there's sheets of rain; there's a desperate rescue; and then there's Ruby in Sam's bed as he sits vigilant in a comely muscle shirt, ogling her exposed armpit and nervously clutching hand. With this porcelain beauty nearly drowning, then moping frumpily about, you might suspect you're watching The Hours 2 -- God frickin' forbid! -- but unlike in that probable Oscar hog, there's a good reason behind this shared sadness.
The real mystery is threefold: Why was this project shelved since 2001? Why does it bear an absurdly unmerited R rating? And where did Ruby come from? Only this last question bugged the audience. She awakens from her waterlogged trauma with acute amnesia -- it's mildly amusing to watch the star of Memento helping her regain her memory -- and thereafter she alternates between headstrong strides and desperate confusion. Her presence causes Sam to revisit elements of his youth -- a lively folk dance, a mildly annoying word-association game, the home of an old crone who may have been a witch -- and a wistful love emerges. Both Pearce and Bonham Carter possess obvious reservoirs of the sadness that leads to bad habits like smoking or acting, and their authority dismantles the whole origin question; Ruby just is.
Sometimes it's easy to spot an anima -- that essential feminine aspect of males, most commonly lost (or violently snuffed) in adolescence. It's not too bombastic to say that this separation -- and its subsequent longing -- could be the cause of a plethora of woes, intimate and global. Bonham Carter very sagely symbolizes that loss that makes men close down. She may not do it for everyone, though at least she's dropped her Planet of the Apes makeup and indeed looks rather fetching when backlit, with a sanguine tint in her meticulously tousled locks.
There's a somber tone to Petroni's work here, enhanced by Roger Lanser's shadowy cinematography and handicapped a bit by a shmaltzy Hollywood-type score, and there's also plenty of episodic "life" stuff. From young Sam's induction into the practice of husbandry by Silvy's robustly Scots papa (a fine Frank Gallacher) to adult Sam's grownup reappraisal of himself, the movie takes on the feel of poetry. This is fitting, because it draws heavily from T.S. Eliot's "The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock," a rather scintillating work of life and depth that functions as a skeleton key to this film's lyricism.
Join My Voice Nation for free stuff, film info & more!