Dave Matthews Band

If you've been waiting for Dave Matthews to release a recording capable of justifying his massive popularity, keep waiting. His latest isn't so much terrible as typical -- a minor variation on the college rock he's been making since his first batch of supporters actually were in college.

Related Content

• Dave Matthews & Tim Reynolds, Old 97's, Black Angels shows announced
  October 13, 2010
• Liz Phair on Exile, Funstyle and being a studio geek
  January 14, 2011
• Lizzy Allen of Vitamins tells us how she ended up singing backing vocals for the Flaming Lips
  August 3, 2011
• Tonight: Bobby Long at the Bluebird
  February 10, 2011
• Mile High Music Festival day two travelogue: My Morning Jacket and Bassnectar
  August 15, 2010

More About

• Dave Matthews

Progress? None to speak of. Although Davey offers up some genre exercises, his excursions into blues ("Hello Again") and boogie ("Louisiana Bayou") are about as authentic as Olestra. The title cut and "American Baby" work better because they've got decent if overly familiar grooves, but "Everybody Wake Up (Our Finest Hour Arrives)" is burdened by stereotypically topical lyrics and a notably contradictory title. If the song really represented Matthews's finest hour, everybody would already be awake.

Whenever Matthews puts out snoozy CDs, his apologists claim the material will sound better live, and that's certainly possible; it can't be duller than it is on disc. Still, anyone who's not a true believer will likely react to Stand Up by taking a seat. Or a nap.