Various Artists

Artist-salute discs make plenty of sense from a business standpoint, since they let labels milk material that was paid for long ago. Problem is, they're almost always lame -- and this homage to Freddie Mercury and friends certainly doesn't buck the trend.

Related Content

• America Idol in Portland: The judges were spot on, but the contestants were a mixed bag
  February 2, 2012
• Constantine Maroulis and Jim Breuer at Rock of Ages party tonight at Rockaway
  June 23, 2011
• American Idol in St. Louis: When the contestants are good, they're really good
  February 3, 2012
• American Idol in Pittsburgh: Judges still too soft
  January 20, 2012
• American Idol is back, with a new host of hopefuls
  January 19, 2012

More About

• Joss Stone
• Gavin DeGraw
• Freddie Mercury
• Television
• Reality Shows

There are lots of ways to go wrong on this sort of project, and Killer Queen finds most of them. Over-singing? Check out Joss Stone's evisceration of "Under Pressure" and Gavin DeGraw's Ramada Inn-ready take on "We Are the Champions." Moronic new arrangements? Look no further than Be Your Own Pet's idiotic sprint through "Bicycle Race." Overtly aping the original vocalist? Failed American Idol contestant Constantine Maroulis covers that while returning to "Bohemian Rhapsody," which wowed Simon, Randy and Paula, but probably only because they'd just been subjected to Anthony Federov.

Fortunately, the Flaming Lips' rendition of "Rhapsody" is everything that Constantine's turn isn't: fresh, witty and odd. More tracks like it would have made this collection as good a deal for album buyers as it is for the record company.