OutKast

Idlewild is a disappointment when compared with OutKast's Speakerboxx/The Love Below double-header. But it's also an entirely different animal -- a soundtrack yoked to the like-titled film's strained attempt to transplant hip-hop to the 1930s. Given this unwieldy concept, André and Big Boi deserve a few props for producing an intermittently enjoyable platter rather than a flat-out disaster.

Related Content

• The ten greatest southern rappers of all time
  March 25, 2013
• Ten acts that helped make hip-hop more accessible to mainstream audiences
  February 15, 2013
• Ten best hip-hop shows in Denver this month
  May 3, 2013
• The 50 best rap lyrics of all time: 50-26
  March 13, 2013
• The 50 best rap lyrics of all time: Complete list
  March 14, 2013

More About

• OutKast
• Snoop Dogg
• Lil' Wayne
• Hip-Hop and Rap
• Dirty South

With a few exceptions (including the catchy nugget "Idlewild Blue"), throwback elements cause the most problems. The Cab Calloway allusions in "Mighty ŒO'" make André seem like a mini-moocher, and the collision of vintage crooning and guest spots by Lil' Wayne and Snoop Dogg turns "Hollywood Divorce" into something every bit as messy as a real-life celebrity bust-up. Yet "Peaches" works up a subtly funky groove, and "Makes No Sense at All" scores points for sheer honesty thanks to a hook that asks, "How in the hell do we get ourselves in these situations?"

The answer is ambition, and that's a good thing. But while the OutKasters certainly haven't been idle, the results fall short of wild.