A Cure for the Common Cold Case

In June 1975, Howard and Virginia Morton got a call from the boss of their eighteen-year-old son, Guy, in Arizona. He said that Guy had hitchhiked to Phoenix to try to get back the deposit on a car he couldn't afford, and never returned to work.

A dozen years later, a retired sheriff's deputy read a newspaper story about the Mortons' search for their son and remembered a skeleton found in the desert in 1975. The remains had been misidentified by a medical examiner and destroyed. The Mortons, who'd moved from Kansas City to Colorado in 1980, ultimately sued Maricopa County over the mishandling of their son's body and continued to search for his killer. In 1995, they joined the Front Range chapter of Parents of Murdered Children, which Howard was soon chairing.

But Howard didn't agree with one of PMC's programs: Murder Is Not Entertainment, a protest of crime dramas on TV. The Mortons liked to watch those shows. They followed Dr. Mark Sloan, the police consultant played by Dick Van Dyke on Diagnosis Murder, and they sat through rerun after rerun of Murder, She Wrote. "Those of us who have been hit by a murder in our family want to see the murder solved, so we watch these shows and see they can be solved, they do get solved, and we like that. We root for the cops," Howard says, and pauses. "We actually root for the cops."

Howard knows that cops make mistakes, that a lot of murders go unsolved because of bad investigations or no investigations — like not recognizing a murder scene for what it is until days or weeks have passed, as was the case in the disappearance of Paul and Sarah Skiba and Lorenzo Chivers. Morton knows there are good cops, too, dogged guys and gals who take their cases to bed with them every night. But even the good ones can only handle so many cases.

"When a new crime of violence pops up, guess what happens? Except in Denver and a couple of other places, that investigator gets yanked off whatever he's doing," Howard explains. "Denver has several investigators who are working exclusively on unsolved murders, but even Denver can't get their arms around all the cases they have to address. They're looking at 604 unsolved murders."

And that's just since 1970.

In 2001, Howard formed Families of Homicide Victims and Missing Persons — a group that would hold law enforcement accountable for unsolved murders. The first thing he had to do was find out just how many Colorado cases were unsolved.

Howard's group petitioned 108 municipalities to come up with the total number of murder victims whose cases had not been solved: 1,250. And Morton started advocating for the creation of a statewide, state-funded unit with full-time investigators specially trained to tackle cold cases. Such an endeavor would take significant funding, and last year Representative Paul Weissmann sponsored a bill to repeal the death penalty and fund a cold-case squad with the savings from death-penalty cases. Between the Attorney General's Office and the judicial branch, the state now spends nearly $800,000 annually on death-penalty cases — and only one person has been executed in Colorado since 1972. Weissmann's bill died in the House, but a smaller, less controversial measure did pass: HB 1272, sponsored by Representative Joe Rice, which gave $67,822 to the Colorado Bureau of Investigation to assemble a database of all the open homicides in the state, and created a cold-case task force that is supposed to report back to the legislature with recommendations for solving those cases.

Audrey Simkins, criminal intelligence analyst with the CBI, is now compiling the data on cold cases — defined as unsolved murders at least three years old. She will cross-reference what she finds with FOHVAMP's database, which includes year-old cases, and the end product will be two CBI-maintained databases — one for law enforcement and one for the public. "We're essentially hoping to be able to outline how many cases are outstanding and then go back and review those cases," she says. "The bill allows local law enforcement to request assistance from CBI" — even if it doesn't include any funding for that assistance.

"If you're going to attack a problem, one of the first things to do is take inventory," says Kathy Sasak, deputy executive director of the Colorado Department of Public Safety, who's heading up the cold-case task force. A prosecutor for 23 years, Sasak says that often cold cases are just waiting on the right lead, and the public database could be key. "A lot of times, cold cases are cold not because law enforcement doesn't know who did it," she says, but simply because they don't have enough evidence to prove it. With a public database, people who know something about a murder can check on the status of a case and perhaps be inspired to come forward. "We're looking for needles in haystacks," Sasak admits.