-
Jim Monty 07/21/2011 5:09:00 AM
Fuck you, your article is simply bullshit. Classic Rock will never die. Young people listen to it for the same reason it is the most popular station in the nation, because it is superior to newer music. You see, a good song has a good rhythm, harmony, and lyrics. A excellent song has all that and tells a story. People who listen to Classic Rock don't lack imagination, they listen to it because the new artist (majority) lack it. Sure, some songs a way over played, that's why you find obscure artists that are equally as good, such as: Supertramp, Jefferson Airplane, The Doors, Alice Cooper, Todd Rundgren, Night Ranger, The list goes on and on. In the words of Neil Young: "Hey Hey, My My, Rock and Roll CAN NEVER DIE.
-
Joe 01/14/2011 8:47:00 PM
Many younger people like me listen to classic rock and 80s glam metal bands because today's music sucks, not because we lack imagination. I'm going to crank up some Def Leppard, Whitesnake and Scorpions.
-
sb 06/16/2009 6:17:00 AM
Ben - Your article is a perfect parallel to the recent classic rock radio burnout I've been experiencing. My personal tastes do lean toward 60s & 70s rock, but I prefer the less mainstream artists (Cat Stevens, Jefferson Airplane, Joni Mitchell... stuff that rarely gets played on the radio).
The rotations on all of the local classic rock stations (in Denver and in every city I've ever lived in) are so repetitive and shallow it's pathetic. Why do these stations insist on playing the same old 3 or 4 Stones songs over and over when they could be playing obscure tracks from Exile or Beggar's Banquet? How many times can you play Stairway to Heaven before you realize people might want to hear Four Sticks or You Shook Me for a change?
So I finally decided I couldn't take it anymore and made the switch to Indie 101.5. It has been so refreshing to catch vintage Jane's Addiction, brand new Sonic Youth, and some great stuff from bands I'd never even heard of up until now.
While 60s & 70s rock is my first love when it comes to music, I can no longer stomach corporate radio's brand of "Classic Rock." And if this truly is my generation's idea of "Classic Rock," then you're absolutely right -- these people are just as lazy and unimaginative as our nation's DJs.
-
Hal Dixon 06/10/2009 10:05:00 PM
Hey there Mr. b from Denver,
Have you ever heard of Cristy Hines? How about Bob Hope? Any idea where they came from? Ever heard of Hank Williams? Maybe they are not born in Akron, but that's what they started. Later my friend...
-
Chris 05/29/2009 5:40:00 PM
I'm 54. I destroyed my classic rock collection years ago. Now, I scour the earth for the hottest and most refreshing new music I can find ... I wish more radio would quit pandering to the idea that we're all tied up in the 70s; when many of the musicians we adored then are still recording relevant material now. I choose not to be tied to my past, but to look forward to today's sounds and tomorrow's. Too bad our kids are getting sucked into the Land of the Lost.
-
David 05/25/2009 12:21:00 AM
More angry rantings from a holier-than-thou hipster. Maybe people still listen to classic rock because it's simply better than the crap-infused list you spouted in your article. And maybe, just maybe, people actually prefer rock bands that weren't all shoe gazing whiny emo crap.
-
Steven 05/24/2009 5:42:00 AM
Today's music sucks. Have you seen John Fogerty play guitar? Jimmy Page? Have you heard Billy Gibbons? Ritchie Blackmore, Jon Lord? Richard Wright on keyboards, David Gilmoure? Have you ever heard Rob Halford sing? These are highly talented musicians.
What are we going to do with nickleback, they just put out a monolithic block of sound, no bass guitar no guitar solo, no imagination. There are no instruments in todays music just computer generated bumps and some filthy ignorant negro screaming about nothing. Ever heard Earth Wind and Fire? Rick James, Mother's Finest? This music comes from the heart. If there was any talent in your generation maybe we could find something to listen to, otherwise we'll stick with guitars, keyboards, bass guitars, background singers, and talented musicians creating imaginative music that comes from the heart.
Today's generation has the opportunity to hear today's music, and they are choosing classic rock because it sounds better, that's not a sickness it's just good taste, something you obviously lack. The only sickness here is coming from you.
-
Sean 05/23/2009 5:30:00 AM
The reason most people know the words to You Shook Me All Night Long is that it's abysmally simple and repetitive. It only needs to be heard once or twice to be remembered. Can you say that about any TV on the Radio song? No, and that's not exactly a bad thing.
People who *like* classic rock aren't lacking in imagination any more than people who like Edward Hopper or F. Scott Fitzgerald.
BUT when people say "There's no good music nowadays" (which is different), they aren't so much lacking imagination as just being lazy and naive.
-
Jason 05/23/2009 5:10:00 AM
This is journalism at its finest. It cuts right to the core, directly and succinctly. Clearly a brilliant mind was behind this illuminating act of literary heroism. I don't know about other media consumers, but frankly I am SICK of all the articles I read in my daily routine. The journalists have lost their ability to focus on what is really important -- the TRUTH. THIS ARTICLE, however, has single-handedly restored my faith in the media. Thank you so much for this tremendous work. I feel as though my life experience has been instantly enriched and consummated.
-
Jake 05/22/2009 6:46:00 PM
Let's burn all Mozart while we are at it. As a guitarist, should I be studying Hendrix or the latest Miley Cirus album. You can pry my Zeppelin LP's from my cold dead hands.
-
Arsenio 05/22/2009 1:40:00 PM
First: Very nicely written. Second, I'm guessing that people still listen more to what they like than to what they think they "should" listen to. So the relevant question is really "Why do people like ELO, Queen, et. al more than My Morning Jacket?" One theory I like says that whereas '50s-'70s rockers tended to draw on much of what went before them (blues, country, Broadway...) and add it to their mix, young rockers draw mostly on previous rockers. There is less, in other words, feeding into their stream, resulting in stagnation.
-
Nathan 05/22/2009 2:32:00 AM
I feel dumb for getting involved, but I just had to comment.
First off, I still listen to Cab Calloway and Benny Goodman. Second, if good music can come out of Denver, then why not Akron? Denverites bashing Akron is just silly. (and the other way around)
Third, I think the difference between then and now is niche marketing. Not as many people know of My Morning Jacket as did The Beatles in 1964. And most of the stuff that everyone knows about (britney spears or whatever) is designed for 12 year-olds. crud, well thought out, huh?
-
Steve 05/22/2009 2:12:00 AM
Granted, I'm an old fart, but when I was younger, I WAS listening to both Janis Joplin and Cab Calloway, The Beatles and Duke Ellington. I also listened to Bach, Mozart and Tchaikovsky, as well as Frank Zappa. To me, if it's good music, it's good music. I don't care if it's Chuck Berry, Motown, NIN or Green Day - it's all good. But I can see how a small mind can be worried, "Wahhh, nobody's listening to MY generation's music!". Come back down to reality. You'll find plenty of people who listen to Neko Case, My Morning Jacket...it's all music, dude!
-
b 05/21/2009 10:48:00 PM
and hal, not all of us living a mile high are "oxygen starved". And we certainly wouldn't trade thin air for the music scene in Akron.
-
AA 05/21/2009 10:47:00 PM
Fine, I'll trade in my Eagles and Doobie Bros albums, but I don't care what you say, I'm keepin my Steely Dan box set.
-
b 05/21/2009 10:44:00 PM
why does this read like it was written by some angry hipster in a coffee shop who is mad because he realized his "authentic" appreciation for classic rock was no more "authentic" than the kids he didn't like in high school's appreciation for the same music?
-
T Moran 05/21/2009 6:10:00 AM
Sorry Ben, but until the new crop of songwriters and recording artists come up with something better, we will continue to embrace 'The Classics'. So far, all we hear is whiny lyrics, pop tarts, incompetent bands [self-proclaimed 'Punks'] and trendily-dressed assembly-line groups who won't last longer than one hit. Those "moldy" artists like Billy Joel and The Beatles have created timeless music that will far outlive the pap that is new pop. Get used to it. They're going to be around for a long time.
-
Wilson 05/21/2009 5:09:00 AM
Really to go so far as to call classic rock cancer is ridiculous, the age of the music shouldn't decree your level of appreciation for it. I'm active in the indie and jam band communities and both have very large followings for bands of our generation. And have you even seen any of the shows you're speaking of? My Morning Jacket, TV on the Radio and Of Montreal were all packed. MMJ was a major act for Lollapalooza in 2007 and played Red Rocks last year for an estimated 8,000 in attendance. Get involved in the music community a bit more, and maybe go to some shows before you publish absolutely absurd articles like this.
-
Hal 05/20/2009 10:55:00 PM
Dearest Benny,
Are you a bedwetter? Did something happen to you in your younger years? There's nothing wrong with Benny Goodman, Glenn Miller, Neil Diamond and those "old timers'' you disparage. If it's music, it's good -- maybe not for you, but there are many many people who should take you to task for your malignant opinions, but it's a free country. Maybe if you weren't in Denver your brain would not be oxygen starved. Thanks for your opinion.