Top

news

Stories

 

Asylum Denied: Only a fraction of Mexicans get U.S. asylum

Photo: Diane Sierra
Mexican nationals running for their lives flee the violence in their hometowns and make for the border, where many turn themselves in to U.S. officials and ask for asylum.

As evening falls on southern Mexico, Sarah (not her real name) is shopping at a fruit market a block from her house. It is Friday, and her father, an investigator for the State Judicial Police, is home relaxing on his night off. Wearing blue jeans and an unbuttoned shirt, he is sweeping his front porch, waiting for his daughter to return and make dinner.

Eduardo Beckett, attorney for the El Paso nonprofit Las Americas Immigrant Advocacy Center is leading the legal battle to help innocent Mexicans caught up in the drug violence gain asylum and protection in the United States.
Photo: Diane Sierra
Eduardo Beckett, attorney for the El Paso nonprofit Las Americas Immigrant Advocacy Center is leading the legal battle to help innocent Mexicans caught up in the drug violence gain asylum and protection in the United States.

Sarah pays for the food just as a rush of black SUVs with no license plates speed past her along the road. She recognizes them instantly as they pull up to her home in a cloud of dust. Men in dark masks with AK-47s jump out and run toward Sarah's front door. Two of them are wearing police patches. One of them is her father's commander.

"They're taking your dad! They're taking your dad!" shouts a little girl in the store. Sarah tries to run, but her legs won't churn fast enough. Everything is in slow motion. She watches the gunmen drag her father out onto the street while he screams, "Show me the arrest warrant! Don't take me!" Sarah sees the men punch her mother and shoot her father in the leg, before hauling him into a truck and driving away.

By the time Sarah gets home, all that is left of her father is the blood-stained pavement. He has not been seen since.

For Sarah and her family, years of intimidation and abuse by corrupt police officers have come to a head. Her father, a member of the anti-kidnapping unit, had discovered that his commander had taken a young girl hostage and that he and other cops were working for the cartels.

Sarah's father tried to bring his commander to justice, denouncing him to Mexico's National Human Rights Commission, but there were no arrests and it just made him a target. Crooked policemen and cartel thugs had threatened to kill him, beaten Sarah and raped his wife, but he refused to work for drug traffickers.

After the kidnapping, Sarah and her mother rushed to the Public Prosecutor, but officials refused to take a statement. The women told nearby police agencies about the corruption and abduction, but no one would help. In desperation, Sarah went to the state capital to ask the military to intercede, but once again, she was turned away.

Sarah spent the next few nights in hiding at her uncle's home. She needed to get farther away. Sarah had family in Juarez, and while going to one of the most violent cities in the western hemisphere for sanctuary is like going to hell to cool off, her uncle put her on a plane.

When Sarah landed, she found out that her uncle had been murdered outside the airport for helping her escape.

In Juarez, Sarah met up with her mother and two younger brothers, who also had managed to get away, and for two months they hunkered down in an apartment.

"I was living in shock," says Sarah. "I was unable to understand that life as I knew it was over forever. I was so scared that I only stayed inside, living in my world of fear."

One afternoon, Sarah's mother received a phone call from a hometown friend. Her father's commander was threatening to kill Sarah's grandparents if they or any family member spoke to the fugitives. Even worse, said the friend, the commander and his troops knew where Sarah and her mother were hiding in Juarez.

"I felt like my world was collapsing," says Sarah. "I did not know where to turn or where to run."

The next morning, Sarah and her mother heard over the radio that the United States was offering protection. Sarah had never thought of living among los gringos; her life was in Mexico, where the 21-year-old was already halfway through law school. But now she was out of options. The corrupt police knew her location, and they were coming.

Later that day, December 30, 2008, Sarah, her mother and her two brothers walked up to the Paseo Del Norte Port of Entry in El Paso and turned themselves in, requesting asylum.

Sarah was separated from her family and placed in a detention center for more than a year while she waited for her day in immigration court. When a judge finally heard the case, her claim for asylum was denied and she was ordered back to Mexico. The evidence — that cops working for a drug cartel had beaten Sarah, killed her uncle, abducted her father and raped her mother because her father fought against their illegal activities – was moot. Sarah did not meet the U.S. government's standard for asylum.

If the line between the Mexican government and the drug world ever existed, it is less distinct now then ever. Cartels take over one village, town or state at a time, and buy police departments and armies along the way, fighting for control of precious drug routes and dollars. Since 2006, more than 28,000 people have been killed in the drug violence in Mexico. If someone speaks up, he is silenced, usually with a bullet made in the United States. Mexican citizens have nowhere to turn. Except north.

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Next Page >>
 
  • Sandy 09/13/2010 7:22:00 AM

    I read stupid comments like "not an open border" and "we do not have millions of illegals from other nations. Just Mexico and they do not even allow illegals in from so or central America". Any border is open to people who are willing to risk their lives to cross it. Just like the Europeans did by coming to America. Survival of the fittest, right? How the hell can any intelligent person reply to the second quote? I'll use small words for you... let me know if I go too fast. Millions of illegals? So how many millions are we talking about? Maybe these "illegals" should start getting some respect. Strength in numbers, right? It is pure ignorance saying that all illegals come from Mexico, not from South or Central America. Do you bother reading the news? 72 people were killed in Mexico and they were all from south of Mexico. Mexico is only a gateway to the north. Did I go to fast for you or do you need a map?

  • Jan 09/10/2010 11:55:00 AM

    I am really getting tired of all this "poor Mexicans" propoganda. There is violence everywhere, and with the huge influx of illegal Mexicans it's now in Denver. Don't tell me about all these "innocents" in Mexico. How about all the innocents here in the U.S. that are now victims of the Mexican gangs??

  • Chris 09/09/2010 9:55:00 PM

    Brian- On the contrary. Most Americans have common sense and are practical when it comes to illegal and legal immigration. It surely comforts me to know that the vast majority of US citizens aren't open-border, bleeding heart cunts like yourself.

  • Rodney Chapman 09/01/2010 8:01:00 PM

    First off I would like to say Anon you are wrong. There are millions of other immigrants that come here. Go to any major city and you will find Russians, European's, middle easterner's, and Asians. The so called concept of 'Diversity" is a major failure. Most immigrants do not assimilate, they create their own communites and are extremely clonish. As far as this article goes I find it rather amusing that the author get's in his jab at the United States by mentioning that the bullet was probably manufactured in the United States. Would someone please tell me what the Hell difference it makes as to where the bullet was made? It is Mexican citizens killing Mexican citizens. And now due to the leniency of un-controlled immigrtion we have citizens of all countries killing citizens of America, natural or illegal, here on American soil. I'm sorry folk's, dead is dead, it doesn't matter where you are from.

  • mr usa 09/01/2010 4:49:00 AM

    i say we show mexico why we are thu usa and go down there and whoop sum cartel and illegal policia ass right fkn now. mexico is turning into a bigger shit hole than it already is and now there bringing thur bs to our country, lets go teach them who the fuck is boss.

  • nancy 09/01/2010 3:19:00 AM

    WHY SHOULD THEY GET THAT. WE GO THERE AND YOU DONT DO IT FOR US. YOUR MEXICO HAS SO MUCH HATE AND CRIME AND AGAINST US. I SAY HELL NO

  • anon 08/31/2010 8:32:00 PM

    YEsterday the govt of Mex announced they fired 10 percent of the once honest federal police. Sad that so many are so corrupt. time for a wara there. The cartels fight everyone else runs. Time to take a stand. Mexico did for independence. What is wrong with it now ? If they are such hard workers make them work there. we do not have millions of illegals from other nations. Just Mexico and they do not even allow illegals in from so or central America.

  • 1aspencountry 08/31/2010 4:33:00 PM

    Thank to GOD that He is FAIR!!!. Maybe it is time that illegals start packing and get beck home to fight for better life in their own countries!!! We do not have anything against people who are coming here as visa allowed them and go beck home.People in Mexico choose their President, time to learn more about any candidate before give You OK for. I can see in Roofing business, one legal and 4-5 illegals. Can You people imagine how many jobs could be safe if not Constructions Contractors??????? That is were economy grows and that is the reason why America is going down!!!!!Giving us one case is a joke. Time for this illegals to stop using excuses and start defending them self. USA sending billions to Mexican Government to defend borders and to destroy drug cartels and it is getting worse every day. 75 people from other country killed , and what is Mexican Government doing??? nothing!!!!!

  • Carmen M. 08/31/2010 9:12:00 AM

    I could not agree with you more Will. Perhaps sending Latin America condoms instead of our tax dollars would be of great benefit.

  • Bryan 08/31/2010 7:06:00 AM

    A clearly intelligent and urgent news piece concerning humanity; and yet mostly comments displaying genuine; pathetic ignorance. Much like the story itself, such a display is a travesty. One thing surely comforts me -- not all of us are self-centered, inhumane American cunts.

  • Tony 08/31/2010 1:46:00 AM

    I don't like Mexican Drug Cartels. I wish they could be dragged in front of God and brought to justice. Too bad it's wrong to kill people, otherwise I'd get all clever like and start wasting thugs in the hundreds until I was caught or killed. Sorry.

  • Maggie 08/30/2010 10:39:00 PM

    To Reason: The other people that you list come into this country legally. If the people from Mexico would do the same, this country and its people, would not have problem with them being here.

  • joe 08/30/2010 5:20:00 PM

    Sucks to be her. Maybe if the people of their nation would get off their lazy butts and fight back they would have a decent country to live in. America is full. Get over it. We don't want anymore tired and hungry.

  • patrick 08/30/2010 2:00:00 PM

    Change has to come from the people, not outside, when are we going to figure that out. And yes, at the expense of lives.

  • sr 08/30/2010 6:54:00 AM

    I'm so sorry, Sarah. If you had come into the country illegally, Obama would have protected you. But since you tried to come in legally, he wouldn't. He only wants criminals here.

  • Reason 08/30/2010 5:58:00 AM

    When I see the comments from the readers it alarms me that you are so quick to make your decision. I would first like to say it seems like every time immigration is mentioned Hispanic people are the first you thrown stones at. They make up 50% of the immigration issue. What about the Asian, Canadians, Russian etc. Don't you realize that Mexico is our neighbor and if we ignore this problem now we definitely will have to deal with it later. I would rather help out Mexico and our western hemisphere to bring about civility then to be spending the BILLIONS and BILLIONS of DOLLARS every week in Afghanistan or Iraq. You are the cowards and bigots.

  • anon 08/29/2010 7:46:00 PM

    As An American Hispanic I do not NOT want these people here and they bring the violence with them now. I m old enough to remember when they rounded up Mexican American and sent them over the border but most of the 3 or more generation Hispanics, PEW got it wrong on the data btw, are fed up and do not want to be even considered to be these people. If you cannot trust the law there or the prosecutors then I do not want them here anymore. I have see my states crime rate jump and now that many have self deported it is going back down again. Thank god! They get WiC and Food stamps here depite the law. Do not tell me it is about the education either. I work in the schools and see the high rate of the kids failing or dropping out especially the girls. parents never even give us no cell phone nos to contact them when they are sick. 1/3 of the immigrant students here are failing. parents yank them out of school to translate or work on the farms. Now if they kept the kids in mexico, kept the Mex govt ouf of the worker permit program. they cut to a cut and use blackmail to send farm workers here and mandated migrant workers had to send half of all pay home it would not be so bad.

  • tim 08/29/2010 7:19:00 PM

    life sucks...America is full. America's economy is sinking deeper and deeper into the trash. America needs to fix America before we can hand out tickets for our gravy train.

  • Joe 08/29/2010 5:20:00 PM

    Sorry that is happening to Mexicans that live in Mexico. They really need to rise up and fix their own country instead of running like cowards to ours. Because as soon as they get here they're going to start lecturing us on the injustice here and wanting someone else to fight their battles and divide us even more. Getting tired of the victim routine from these people.

  • bigwave 08/29/2010 3:21:00 PM

    I agree the Mexican people are complacent. This is because most have known nothing else, they are also ignorant. Maybe the people should rise up.

  • bigwave 08/29/2010 3:14:00 PM

    .In addition, more importantly decriminalization would save innocent lives and keep illegal immigration to a minimum

  • Old_Dame 08/29/2010 3:06:00 PM

    This happens in Mexico because the government is corrupt and the people are complacent. Sorry but it is true. The only way this changes is when the people take back control of their country and demand appropriate behavior of all the citizens. Mexico could be one of the strongest countries in the world if they overcame their corrupt government. The people individually are strong and resourceful. Collectively they let the worst run the show.

  • Bigwave 08/29/2010 3:01:00 PM

    medicalize instead of criminalize is a more logical approach. I think it would cost half or less then crimilization. Less prisons and taxes for the goverment. A well managed program would put the US out of debt in five years

  • Bad Wolf 08/29/2010 6:52:00 AM

    That's just a frankin shame

 
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy