Top

news

Stories

 

The legislature also set a date — July 1, 1996 — to review the law and decide whether it should continue, in accordance with Colorado's sunset process. The 1995 sunset review report, written by DORA, illustrates that the attitude toward midwifery in Colorado was still hostile. Even so, DORA recommended that the profession continue to be legal.

"The practice of direct-entry midwifery poses a significant potential for harm to the health and safety of the public," the report said, adding that "the regulatory program provides the service of protecting the public's health."

******

Indra Lusero is putting her law degree to work for midwives.
anthony camera
Indra Lusero is putting her law degree to work for midwives.
Indra Lusero in a family photo, shortly after giving birth to Eliot Indigo.
anthony camera
Indra Lusero in a family photo, shortly after giving birth to Eliot Indigo.

On April 9, 2001, Allison gave birth to the family's first son, Zian Lewis. He was born at the hospital with Flame acting as a doula — someone who provides emotional and physical, but not medical, support during labor.

By the time Allison and Indra met Flame, Allison was eight and a half months pregnant and felt it was too late to switch her plan of giving birth in the hospital. But Flame agreed to help her labor at home, drug-free, for twelve hours until she was ready to push. Spending that time at home, Allison says, made a world of difference.

Though Allison delivered Zian without complications or many medical interventions — no epidural, no C-section — Indra wasn't thrilled with the hospital's care. As soon as Allison arrived, they hooked her up to a heart monitor that required her to lie still. "It felt constraining," Indra says. "Suddenly she's plugged in, and it's kind of like, 'Aaah! Does she need to be plugged in? She's okay.' There was just a shift in the texture and meaning."

And after Zian was born, nurses whisked him away. "The nurses are poking and prodding him and sticking tubes down his throat and giving him a shot in his heel," Indra says. "It felt harsh and abrupt, and it felt cold. It was completely counter to my instincts, and I didn't feel like I could do anything..

But Zian was healthy, and they soon took him home. Geoffrey was still living in California and had planned to stay there, but he changed his mind and moved to Denver when Zian was two months old. The women amended a parenting contract they'd drawn up in order to split parental and monetary responsibilities three ways. Soon afterward, Geoffrey met his partner, Mark Thrun, a doctor at Denver Health. (Thrun ran unsuccessfully for a state House seat last year.) Eventually, the contract was amended to include him, too.

Now the family lives in a charming Highland duplex: the moms (Mommy and Mimi) on one side, and the dads (Daddy and Papi) on the other. A doorway connects the two sides, and Zian and Eliot, now ages nine and seven, respectively, go back and forth: two weekdays with the moms, two weekdays with the dads, a rotating Friday/Saturday schedule and everyone together on Sundays for a big dinner. But their family, Indra insists, isn't just the six of them. Instead, she describes it as, "a big, chosen family consisting of co-parents, friends and lovers."

Back when Zian was the only child, Geoffrey lived in a row house next to Indra and Allison. Almost immediately after Zian's birth, Indra started yearning to get pregnant herself. "I was really excited for my turn," she says. It took only two tries, using Geoffrey's sperm and the same syringe method they'd used before. Once Indra found out she was pregnant, there was no question in her mind or anyone else's about what would happen next.

"When Indra got pregnant, it was a given that we'd spend the money to have the home birth," says Allison, who estimated the cost at around $2,000.

"Flame knew that I was going to have a turn and that I'd be calling her," Indra says. From the start, she says, "I never had a doctor's appointment."

Instead, she had hour-long appointments with Flame that she describes as "not even in the same universe" as doctor's appointments. In addition to measuring her belly and weighing her, Flame asked Indra about what she was eating and how she was feeling. They had in-depth conversations about Indra's fears and concerns, and Flame explained to her what natural birth would feel like and look like. Sometimes the midwife would give her a foot massage. "It was just nourishing and comforting," Indra says.

Eliot Indigo was born on February 21, 2003. With Allison on one side and LuAnne on the other, Indra squatted at the edge of her bed, her arms around their shoulders. For an hour, she pushed — until, without a cry, the baby appeared and Geoffrey caught him in his hands. Afterward, Flame put Eliot on Indra's naked chest, where he nuzzled against her skin. The umbilical cord remained intact; a while later, Zian, towheaded and dressed in Winnie the Pooh footie pajamas, cut it with help from the adults.

"Having Zian there immediately, cuddled up on her lap and my lap and all of us right there on the floor, it was one of those beautiful moments," Allison says.

Geoffrey had another post-birth job: making placenta smoothies. The placenta contains valuable nutrients that the mother loses by giving birth. Eating it to replenish them is a popular theory among holistic birth experts but not many doctors. To Indra, however, it made sense. So Geoffrey cut up the pound-and-a-half placenta with kitchen shears and put pieces of it into a Cuisinart along with yogurt, bananas and strawberries.

« Previous Page
 |
 
1
 
2
 
3
 
4
 
5
 
6
 
7
 
8
 
All
 
Next Page »
 
My Voice Nation Help
27 comments
Dlmakamartha
Dlmakamartha

Women and babies suffer at the hands of doctors and nurses way more than midwives....unnecessary interventions leading to major abdominal surgery.....I am so sorry for every mother/family that has suffered at the hands of any provider....but it is no reason to throw the baby out with the bath water! Tragedies happen in all stages of pregnancy and delivery and the right people need to be held responsible. But it's not a good reason to ban all midwifery or to issue a blanket statement that women should only have their babies in the hospital. Do you research people and make an informed choice for you and your baby....instead of following blindly like sheep.

I've had a baby in the hospital and one at home....I will forever have the rest of my children at one....

Liz
Liz

I have suffered tremendous injuries from a Colorado DEM. They aren't required any formal education. My midwife is currently under investigation for negligence. She tried to offer someone else's prescription to induce my labor because I was post due. She was gravely uneducated in GBS protocol. She wanted to "sterilize" her instruments in a baking pan in my oven. She tried to "PowerBirth" me without my consent (I wasn't dilated completely when she told me to start pushing.) She forcibly broke my water with her finger. She yelled at me to push every ten seconds, that I was wasting my contractions, wasn't working hard enough, didn't want my baby enough. She kept saying she could see the head, but I didn't feel it. After 3 hours of pushing, I was weak. She put oxygen on me because I was going to pass out, but she forgot to turn it on and left me alone in my room. When I transferred to the hospital, she did not take me to the hospital in our emergency plan, but to a hospital farther away because she had a "better relationship with them." She refused to transfer my medical records to the on call OB. I was so swollen from pushing before being dilated that it took over a half an hour, two L&D nurses, and many, many tries to even insert a catheter. The "head" she saw was a blood clot that had formed on my bladder- I was only 6 cm dilated. "Oh, she must have undilated when we got to the hospital," was her response to the OB. After my csection, my surgeon said he had to literally pick my bladder up and put it back where it belonged, I was pushing so hard before complete dilation. My child almost died from her incompetence. He had to be recuisitated at birth. I suffered uterine trauma, a severe prolapse, and I'll be lucky to sustain another pregnancy. My body will never be able to vaginally birth a baby. Dare to call me an "uninformed skeptic?"

LindaRosaRN
LindaRosaRN

Families who have been injured by midwife care are beginning to tell their stories at "Hurt by Homebirth" (http://hurtbyhomebirth.blogspo.... These are horrific stories of gross incompetence resulting in needless deaths and injuries.

On this site, note "Zen's Story" about a Colorado "direct-entry midwife" (DEM) who apparently couldn't tell the difference between a blood clot and crowning of the infant's head (and had a woman pushing for three hours when her cervix was only partially dilated). This DEM also prescribed garlic as vaginal suppositories for Group B Strep infections, etc.

I urge families who have been injured by DEMs to come to the Capitol in Denver on Tuesday, April 19th to speak to the House Judiciary Committee (hearing starts 1:30pm in Room 107) on SB-088, a bill that seeks to expand the midwives' scope of practice.

"Regulation" of midwives has done nothing to protect the public, but only dupe the public that DEMs have the State's blessing to provide what is really alarmingly substandard care.

If you have suffered a loss or injury at the hands of a Colorado direct-entry midwife, please contact me: contact*at*childrenintherapy*dot*org

john
john

Grace S and other closed-minded, uninformed skeptics, please check out the documentary, and website, The Business of Being Born.

Grace S
Grace S

It just AMAZES me that people can be so self-absorbed and egotistical that they would take ANY risk with the birth of their baby, as if it's all about *them* and not their baby. And now these unprofessional midwives want to be able to "play doctor" by using medications and suturing in people's homes!? Why don't they just become OBGYN doctorsi if they REALLY want to help moms deliver their babies? It BOGGLES the mind!

Westword W. Westword
Westword W. Westword

If you would like your comment considered for our Letters to the Editor section, please e-mail me with your name and town (we don't print e-mail addresses)at patricia.calhoun@westword.com.

Leanna14369
Leanna14369

I pray for you and your family and hope this all happens in the best way. I want a midwife, so good luck!!

Karen Robinson, CPM, RM
Karen Robinson, CPM, RM

Because of the way the Department of Regulatory Agencies has collected information regarding homebirths in Colorado, information about perinatal demises is sketchy at best. Some midwives report first trimester miscarriages as perinatal deaths. DORA does not collect details on the surveys midwives complete, so we have no way to know what happened with the demises that have been reported. The Colorado Department of Vital Records also tracks homebirths and their reported demise rate for planned homebirth is less than 3 per 1000--which is what one would expect in the low risk population direct-entry midwives serve.

Karen Robinson, CPM, RMPresidentColorado Midwives Association

2AlbertaA
2AlbertaA

32 yrs ago, my daughter had a home birth with a midwife, nurse studying midwifery and a physician who approved of such and me holding a mirror so she could watch...important since I had been given that choice when she was born. It was wonderfull and within an hour we all sat around the table and ate lasagnia and toasted the great experience and new grandchild. Since then Ive had five grands waterbirths and a greatgrandson by 32 yr old gd.All have been happy and no problem events. New mexico and Colorado are with it....from a believer.

Linda Rosa, RN
Linda Rosa, RN

One thing more...

When things go wrong with lay midwives and home births, there is now a new website for families to tell their tragic stories:

Hurt by Homebirthhttp://hurtbyhomebirth.blogspo...

These heart-rending accounts are a far cry from the hot-tub-poetry-drumming-birth-as-theater sort of event described in this Westword article.

Linda Rosa, RN
Linda Rosa, RN

What I don't see in the Sunset Review or this Westword article is a comparison of death rates -- the bottom line on issue of direct-entry midwives.

The incidence of death of newborns at the hands of direct-entry midwives is appalling high in Colorado, and climbing. The last figures put it at 11.3 deaths per 1000 births. That is DOUBLE the rate of the rest of the state. Also consider that the direct-entry midwives are not involved in high-risk pregnancies, premature births, etc.

For more info, see comments by Amy Tuteur, MD:http://skepticalob.blogspot.co...

Linda Rosa, RNLoveland, CO

inkintheveins
inkintheveins

I heard Indra speak during the Senate hearing and she was absolutely amazing. I spoke too, but got too choked up a couple of times talking about how important home birth is for those of us who choose it. Here is the written version of my testimony: http://www.facebook.com/note.p...

Guest
Guest

"Home birth has long been a controversial issue. Doctors and nurses say it's unnecessarily risky, and they criticize the midwives who deliver babies at home as amateur and insufficiently trained." ------- How absurd! Women have been giving birth how long compared to the "Medical Profession" which has been established how long?

A great book on this is - Witches, Midwives, and Nurses, A History of Women Healers by Barbara Ehrenreich and Deirdre English- original publishing 1973 Feminist Press. It is only 48 pages and well researched and referenced.

Marvelousbobchestnut
Marvelousbobchestnut

The baby on the cover doesn't have nipples or a belly button. Is this because of anti-obscenity laws?

Njcronk
Njcronk

Grace, I think you have never been at a midwifery birth. If you had, you would see the huge difference in quality of care -- by midwives. Here is my story. I've had both. A birth with a midwife and a birth with OBs. I would pick the midwife birth every time if I could.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/...

LindaRosaRN
LindaRosaRN

About that 3 deaths per 1000 births. Shame on Ms. Robinson for presenting this very misleading statistic.

I called Vital Statistics. The Colorado Department of Health Environment has data on direct-entry midwives for 2007-2009: For midwives, the department does not collect data on deaths for the usual perinatal period (i.e. week 20 of pregnancy through 28 days after birth), but only deaths in the neonate period (i.e. first 28 days of life). Then only deaths that occur at home go on the midwives' record. Any distressed infants transferred to a hospital and die there (or are declared dead there) are not added to midwives' kill rate.

And actually, infant deaths with low risk pregnancies should be more like 1 death per 1,000 births. An obstetrician may only see one such death in his whole career.

DORA's data also under-reports midwife-related deaths in a number of ways.

So much for midwives being "experts at normal deliveries." As someone said, "That's like being a pilot who is an expert at flying in good weather."

Linda Rosa, RN
Linda Rosa, RN

Ms Robinson's statement does not seem to jive with the data provided by DORA:

http://www.dora.state.co.us/mi...

Where are those first trimester miscarriages of which you speak? I presume the demises are here, reported as required by Colorado law of register midwives.

Regarding the statistics by the Colorado Department of Vital Records: that rate must be largely for unassisted-by-midwife, spontaneous births. But DORA's data clearly shows that having a registered midwife assist at a home birth puts the death rate over three times that amount (11.3 deaths per 1,000 births).

And look at the huge number of transfers to hospital care. Presumably those are emergencies where lives and staving off injury are dependent on STAT care.

What is sketchy is the number and type of injuries suffered by newborns who survive home deliveries. DORA should be collecting that data as well.

I also note on websites of Colorado midwives that they generally state that home birth is "safe" and even imply that it is safer than hospital care. That is misleading the public.

I agree that adults should be allowed to risk their own fool necks, but putting infants at needless risk is another matter. Seriously, what is more important: having the best possible outcome for an infant or having a pasta party with friends after a delivery?

Bbcatcher
Bbcatcher

Linda, I am trying to research these statistics. Can you give me your source for this number, as I've not been able to verify it? Thanks,Janelle Komorowski, CNMGreeley CO

Guest
Guest

Seriously, you're quoting Dr. Amy??? The woman actually believes the Wax Paper is good science!

 
Loading...