For Masterpiece Cakeshop, coming out against gay weddings is good for business

Sugar rush: You won't find too many alternative lifestyles at Masterpiece Cakeshop, meanwhile. An online petition condemning the Lakewood bakery for its policy of not working with gay weddings garnered well over 4,000 signatures. And last weekend, for the second Saturday in a row, protesters gathered outside the store in an effort to convince owner Jack Phillips to change his mind. But that's not going to happen anytime soon. "If I didn't have strong convictions about the issue in the first place, it wouldn't have come up," Phillips tells Westword. "None of the protests or anything will change that."

It was just three weeks ago that Phillips told Charlie Craig and Dave Mullins, a local couple, that he wouldn't bake a cake for their wedding reception because he didn't believe in gay marriage. Personally hurt but politically motivated, Mullins posted a brief version of their story on Facebook that same day, and the first article appeared on the next day. But even as protesters argued civil liberties outside of Phillips's shop last Saturday, fans of his stance made a point of ordering their confections inside. Right now, Masterpiece has four times the business it usually enjoys this time of year. Positive feedback has come to outweigh the negative "100 to 1," says Phillips.

"My stance comes from my belief in the teachings of the Bible; it's not civil rights or constitutional liberties we're dealing with," Phillips insists. "When I do a first-birthday cake, I imagine the baby in the high chair and the family gathering around and smiling, and I feel like I'm a part of that because I contributed to it. But with gay weddings, I refuse to be a part of that."

Mullins says he and Craig have had no contact with Phillips since they heard his initial refusal, walked out of his store and flipped the place the bird. As the date of their September ceremony in Provincetown, Massachusetts, grows closer, they plan to divide their time between activism and wedding plans. Their continued goal is to raise community awareness and convince Phillips to change the store's policy — not to shut down the bakery altogether.

"It's incredible to have people we barely know stand up for us and hug us and be proud of us," Mullins says of this most recent protest. "It's one thing to read people's messages online and see what they're writing on the Internet, but it's another thing to see them stand up not for just you, but for gay rights in general. We hope we can change the way Masterpiece treats people like us."

My Voice Nation Help
patricia.calhoun moderator editortopcommenter

Athena: I'd love to publish your comment, ideally with your full name/town. If that's okay, send me an e-mail at


As a baker/Cake decorator of 35 years experience (literally around the world) I can say that this cake shop owner isn't a baker who's truly passionate about his chosen occupation...if he was, the personal lives of his customers wouldn't have any bearing on whether or not he did business with them. Perverted behaviour  is overwhelmingly, statistically to be found in the so-called "normal," straight population....this clueless cake-shop owner would be really horrified if he could peek into the lives of some of his "God-fearing" customers.   How would he like it if every time a customer came into his shop, if they wanted to know about his private sexual habits as a condition of being a customer?

Protesting provides a locutus for positive change...always has.


"I guess these people don't work and have nothing better to do with their time."

This statement makes no sense; it displays a cognitive dissonance on the part of cali5510-- people without work wouldn't have the available money to buy those baked goods...make up your mind, please.



It is his bakery and he has ever right to make the rules, regardless of what they are.  Protesting gets  people no where.  I guess these people don't work and have nothing better to do with their time.