Maybe a Bear Ate It!: the review
If Denver four-year-olds make small talk about literature, surely Maybe a Bear Ate It! would come up.
If Denver four-year-olds make small talk about literature, surely Maybe a Bear Ate It! would come up.The picture book has been selected as the book in the state's One Book 4 Colorado preschool reading campaign. In theory, every kid in the sandbox will be reading it.
The story by Robie E. Harris is simple. An unnamed boy or creature -- the drawings by Michael Emberley don't make the protagonist's origins entirely clear -- has lost something. He suspects a bear is responsible. That he lost a book, and is distraught without it, probably contributed to Maybe A Bear Ate It! being selected for the program.
But what should be the dominant question of the book -- where is this misplaced object? -- is replaced by a hunt for who is at fault for its misplacement.
At the risk of spoiling the end, a bear did not in fact eat the mislaid book, and the other suspects are equally faultless. Still, there's something both childlike and adult in the hope that a small loss could stem from a larger force. It's also easy to draw parallels between the accused bear in the title and the rash of bear-related fatalities last summer. In both cases, bears take the fall for the consequences of a messy bedroom and feeding wild animals.
Despite the relatable dread that some power, be it a bear or vengeful God, is controlling our fate and taking our books, Maybe A Bear Ate It! lacks what literary critic James Wood described as "thisness: "[a] detail that draws abstraction toward itself and seems to kill that abstraction with a puff of palpability." What book is the boy missing? Is the protagonist even a boy? What kind of bear would be hungry for a book? These are the questions Colorado pre-schoolers needs answers to, and ones Robie H. Harris fails to provide.
Get the ICYMI: Today's Top Stories Newsletter Our daily newsletter delivers quick clicks to keep you in the know
Catch up on the day's news and stay informed with our daily digest of the most popular news, music, food and arts stories in Denver, delivered to your inbox Monday through Friday.