The Enemy Within
Do you feel snug and secure in your cozy suburban life? Are you happy in your picture-perfect home, with your carefully manicured lawn, your kids and your soccer games and barbecues? Do you feel safe? Well, the creators of Arlington Road, the ponderous new thriller starring Jeff Bridges and Tim Robbins, have gone to great lengths to change all that. Their film is designed to be a wake-up call to the sleepy citizens of our nation, to those who, in their view, have grown fat and complacent during this long period of prosperity and have forgotten that the cost of security is eternal vigilance.
Why do we need to snap out of it? Because the enemy is close at hand. In fact, he's just across the fence in the house next door. The picture--which was directed by Mark Pellington from a screenplay by Ehren Kruger--features Jeff Bridges as Michael Faraday, a professor of American history who specializes in teaching the harsh realities of modern-day terrorism. Actually, to say that Michael teaches his class is not exactly accurate; what he does is rant and harangue his poor, unsuspecting students about every variety of conspiracy in tones that would make any street-corner maniac look sane by comparison. And Michael doesn't just teach a class in terrorism; he lives it. His wife was also in the game, as an FBI agent who, just two years earlier, was killed in a gun battle with a suspected terrorist.
Even before the film has worked up a head of steam, it has started piling up the improbabilities, giving us reason to question its credibility. Still, Bridges manages to piece together a convincing and affecting performance. Michael is a man who has been bludgeoned by life; although he has the support of an understanding new girlfriend, Brooke (Hope Davis), his pain is still right under the surface, and at times he seems to stagger around, almost drunk with grief, unable to move on.
Michael's next-door neighbors have pitched in, too, to help him move past the tragedy. From the moment they first meet, however, Michael feels suspicious of Oliver and Cheryl Lang (Tim Robbins and Joan Cusack). Why does Oliver, who says he is working as an architect on a mall project, have blueprints for something else? And why does he continue to get notices in the mail from the alumni committee of one university when he claims to have gone to another? With these facts in hand, Michael begins to poke around in Oliver's past, and what he finds convinces him that his friendly next-door neighbor may not be exactly what he seems.
Not that any of this comes as a surprise. From the moment he first appears on screen, you don't have to be a raving paranoid to see that Oliver is up to something. And while Oliver's plans remain mysterious, his character generates very little in the way of suspense. As an actor, Robbins has shown tremendous range and authority, but his performance here doesn't belong on the long list of his best efforts. As written, the character is one-dimensional, and that is how it remains despite his considerable skills. Cusack fares no better. As Oliver's wife, she has a couple of choice moments in which she is both scary and funny, but for the most part, she recedes into the background as part of the atmosphere of vague menace.
There is nothing in Pellington's only other feature, Going All the Way, that would indicate he had the talent for this sort of suspenseful thriller. Everything he does here seems perfectly ordinary. If the picture has a style to speak of, it is the generic style of the run-of-the-mill, big-budget studio thriller. What the picture has instead is an agenda. It wants us to open our eyes to the precarious state of our society: Things are far worse than we could have imagined. A war is being waged against the government of the United States by those who feel that it has grown too large and intrusive. Even with our current prosperity, the numbers of those who are convinced that our rights as individuals are being usurped have grown tremendously. And if we don't change our course, an armed conflict is inevitable.
There's nothing subtle about the way the filmmakers have presented their message. They beat it into us with every frame, to the point where you can't help but feel wearied by the attack.
The movie does end with an unexpected twist in the style of O. Henry or Ambrose Bierce, and for some, the surprise may salvage the movie. For the rest of us, though, the ending is simply the last straw.
Directed by Mark Pellington. Screenplay by Ehren Kruger. Starring Jeff Bridges, Tim Robbins, Joan Cusack and Hope Davis.
Get the Film Club Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.