It's impossible to write about David Wain's The Ten without first making passing reference to Krzysztof Kieslowski's Dekalog and Monty Python's The Meaning of Life. The former, originally made for Polish TV twenty years ago and first shown in the United States in 2000, offered a modern-day take on the Ten Commandments, interpreting each within the confines of a Warsaw apartment complex. The latter, of course, found the English comedy troupe bidding adieu with fierce and occasionally grotesque bluster. Never had their comedy — here sliced into vignettes and infused with a disdain for religiosity always hinted at, but never before made so obvious — seemed so ugly and angry (despite some catchy tunes).
The Ten, obsessed with prison rape and puppet dicks, doesn't exactly possess the grand ambitions of Kieslowski's work. Nor does it seethe with the ham-fisted, albeit melodic, fury of the Pythons' finale. Look, whaddaya want — it's from the guys who brought you Wet Hot American Summer, a film whose sole ambition was to remake Meatballs.
And it's not really about the Ten Commandments, anyway. It's just a star-studded, half-baked "goof," in the parlance of co-writer/co-star Ken Marino's surgeon, who's keen on leaving instruments inside his patients' bodies because it makes him giggle. (He's the "thou shalt not kill" commandment, natch.) The Ten doesn't want you to ponder the existence of God or the rights and wrongs laid out by His master plan, just to laugh. And you will more often than not, which is all you can hope for in what might as well be a prolonged episode of The State, from which several of the cast and creators sprang.
The Ten, which features recurring characters who glide in and out of sketches like partygoers in search of someone more interesting to talk to, demands your patience but rewards your fortitude. It's that most fragile of big-screen beasts: the deadpan comedy compendium in which coarse jokes and puerile gags are packaged and presented as ironic, clever and dangerous. The Ten grows increasingly frantic and dopey as it goes, culminating in an animated sequence straight from the underground comix of the 1960s and a musical number in which A.D. Miles and Bobby Cannavale observe the Sabbath by throwing nude Sunday-morning parties, during which they perform Peabo Bryson and Roberta Flack's "Tonight I Celebrate My Love."
Earlier this year, Marino appeared in Diggers, which he wrote as a tribute to his late clam-digging dad. That movie, which also featured Ten co-star Paul Rudd and which Wain produced, was a sweet, gentle, intimate dramedy — the story of four friends trying to keep their heads above water in Long Island in the 1970s. The Ten feels very much like its photo-negative — a playful punch in the nuts after that reassuring pat on the back. At its worst, it's occasionally uneven — you will not find many critics who agree on which sketches are funny.
In one of the best, Gretchen Mol makes an appearance as a good-girl librarian who travels to Mexico and finds herself nailed to the bed by a handyman named Jesus (Justin Theroux). In another, Liev Schreiber's mustachioed cop becomes envious of his neighbor's stash of CAT scan machines — mostly hilarious because Schreiber can't help but play the lowbrow comedy like it's gritty drama.
Weirdly, the interstitial sequences featuring Rudd, usually the best thing about some of the worst movies, are the biggest letdowns. Rudd acts as the film's narrator, only he keeps getting interrupted by his nagging wife (Famke Janssen) and his girlfriend (Jessica Alba). Their love triangle overwhelms and ultimately deflates the movie. Nothing gets in the way of a good prison-rape joke like romantic comedy.
Get the Film & TV Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.