Idlewild is a disappointment when compared with OutKast's Speakerboxx/The Love Below double-header. But it's also an entirely different animal -- a soundtrack yoked to the like-titled film's strained attempt to transplant hip-hop to the 1930s. Given this unwieldy concept, André and Big Boi deserve a few props for producing an intermittently enjoyable platter rather than a flat-out disaster.
With a few exceptions (including the catchy nugget "Idlewild Blue"), throwback elements cause the most problems. The Cab Calloway allusions in "Mighty ŒO'" make André seem like a mini-moocher, and the collision of vintage crooning and guest spots by Lil' Wayne and Snoop Dogg turns "Hollywood Divorce" into something every bit as messy as a real-life celebrity bust-up. Yet "Peaches" works up a subtly funky groove, and "Makes No Sense at All" scores points for sheer honesty thanks to a hook that asks, "How in the hell do we get ourselves in these situations?"
The answer is ambition, and that's a good thing. But while the OutKasters certainly haven't been idle, the results fall short of wild.
Get the Music Newsletter
Keep your thumb on the local music scene each week with music news, trends, artist interviews and concert listings. We'll also send you special ticket offers and music deals.