Jimma Reat's family sues Denver over botched 911 call that led to his death
Earlier this year, we told you about the tragic death of Jimma Reat, a Sudanese immigrant who was killed after a 911 operator told him and his companions to return to Denver after escaping a racially motivated attack. Now, his estate, among others, is suing the city over the incident, alleging that the call led to a "classic example of a 'snake pit' of danger"; see the complete complaint below. But attorneys hope negotiations with Denver can prevent a jury trial.
The complaint was filed by Holland, Holland Edwards & Grossman, a firm whose namesakes are John Holland, Erica Grossman and Anna Holland Edwards. Note that John Holland worked with Alex Landau, whose beating by Denver police resulted in a $795,000 settlement.
As the complaint notes, Reat was 25 at the time of his death. He's described as a hard worker with great life prospects who worked to help support his parents -- and he's said to have been beloved in his community. He and his brother, Ran Pal, scored three consecutive three-point field goals to help win the 2007 state basketball championship for Lincoln High School. Reat was a refugee from what is now South Sudan; he came to the United States from a refugee camp in Ethiopia after escaping his native country with his family.
This move didn't guarantee safety for Reat's family and loved ones. At around 3 a.m. the day after Christmas, as we've reported, Youn Malual, a Sudanese immigrant and father of five whom Reat considered an uncle, was murdered by an unknown assailant near his apartment building at Mississippi and South Xenia in Arapahoe County.
In January, Bruce Williamson, a bureau chief with the Arapahoe County Sheriff's Office, told us that the lack of progress in the case was frustrating. "We really want to get this one going," he said. "From everything we know, he was an upstanding, hardworking man just trying to care for his family. And to be gunned down the way he was...."
The frustration continues: There have been no arrests in Youn Malual's murder to date -- and the same is true of Reat's tragic slaying, which is described in the "Statement of Facts" portion of the document.
Early on April 1, 2012, the narrative says, Reat and two of his brothers, Changkuoth Pal and Ran Pal, as well as Joseph Kolong, were in a vehicle near the intersection of 10th and Sheridan when a Jeep Cherokee pulled up alongside their car. The Jeep's male occupants began "harassing and attempting to injure" the four young men.
The men in the Jeep are said to have called Reat and friends "niggers" while throwing beer bottles and what's described as "bottle rockets" at them. The back window of Reat's car was shattered in the altercation, showering the occupants with broken glass. In addition, one of the Jeep's occupants brandished a handgun.
At that point, the statement continues, Ran Pal phoned 911 to report the crime and get emergency police and medical assistance. The call was answered by Juan Jesus Rodriguez, who's listed as a defendant in the case, along with the City and County of Denver. During the conversation, the victims were able to elude the men in the Jeep and find relative safety at an apartment building's parking lot in Wheat Ridge, approximately seven and a half blocks west of Denver's city limits -- and Ran Pal is said to have told the operator that he was too shocked by the occurrence to feel comfortable driving.
A map showing the distance between the apartment building and the intersection where gunfire rang out.
Nonetheless, the suit alleges, Rodriguez told them they needed to drive back to Denver.
Ran Pal questioned these instructions, but according to the suit, Rodriguez said that if they didn't return to Denver proper, they "would not be allowed to make a report of the criminal violence that had been visited upon them and would not receive emergency protective or medical services."
In the end, Ran Pal and his companions acquiesced. But the complaint maintains that Rodriguez didn't immediately send police to the location within Denver limits (the delay is estimated at seven minutes), nor did he create an incident report. Moreover, the suit says, he told the victims that once they had moved their car to a suitable spot, they should make themselves prominent to officers by turning on their hazard lights and leaving them flashing.
Rodriguez was still on the phone with Ran Pal when the car came to a stop in the vicinity of West 29th and Sheridan -- at which point the Jeep Cherokee rematerialized and its occupants opened fire. Jimma Reat died at the scene in Ran Pal's arms, having been shot in the back.
As pointed out in the narrative, Rodriguez was fired from his position as Emergency Communications Operator in mid-May, with Carl Simpson, representing the city, confirming that he'd put Reat and the others in danger by his actions. He wrote that Rodriguez "showed a blatant disregard for the caller's health in [his[ question to have the caller return to Denver city limits...."
Nonetheless, the lawsuit posits a racial component to the incident, arguing that because Rodriguez knew the victims were black people from the description of what happened and Ran Pal's pronounced African accent, he made a "race-based discriminatory decision to selectively deny immediate police protective services...because of their known status as disfavored minorities." Instead, the complaint says, he "stereotypically profiled and treated them as if they were themselves engaged in gang activity and not equally worthy and in need of immediate criminal protection by law enforcement."
The scene of the crime.
To back up this contention, the lawsuit says Denver police initially tried to determine if Reat and his friends were gang members. Also mentioned are comments made in the press implying the harsh words that prompted the confrontation could have been gang-related.
These elements transition into a section that attempts to place Reat's death in a context of police policy requiring operators to have crime victims return to city limits in order to report incidents. Here's an excerpt:
More particularly, it is the longstanding widespread deliberately indifferent danger creating custom, habit, practice and/or policy for emergency communications operators to regularly refuse to dispatch units where the victims are safely located, and instead direct them to go back into city limits in the proximity of where the attackers were known to have just been or to still be, or even instruct the callers to remain at the scenes involving crimes against persons to meet police.
Denver has, with deliberate indifference, and actual knowledge, failed to mandate as policy or train its operators and dispatchers that in circumstances of reported assaults, they may never direct persons outside of Denver to return to Denver without providing immediate and timely police cover, and a specific protective plan to assure that there is no risk of further attack on such persons by their assailants in following 911 instructions.
This custom, habit, policy and practice has been in widespread effect since at least the 1980s, when it was reported in the media that a few young boys who were being attacked at a McDonald's in Denver, and who had gone to a safe place in Lakewood, were instructed by the Denver 911 operators to return to Denver, where officers would meet them.
In a release about the lawsuit, the Holland, Holland Edwards & Grossman attorneys write that the lawsuit "challenges a set of civil rights violations that have devastated a very loving South Sudanese refugee family, who thought they were finally living in a safe place after having escaped the ravages of war. As a child, Jimma Reat walked and was carried for months by his family from Sudan to a refugee camp in Ethiopia before coming to the United States and settling in Denver."
Jimma Reat, right, with two of the plaintiffs and the newborn child of another of his brothers.
After summarizing the events that led to Reat's death, the release describes how this "traumatic set of preventable events" not only destroyed any opportunity for Reat to fulfill his promise, but also devastated his mother and father, Rebecca Awok Diag and James Reat, as well as Ran Pal, Changkuouth Pal and Joseph Kolong, "who were with him when he was killed, profoundly injured, grieving and in continuing despair."
At the same time, the statement offers credit to Denver and its leadership for straightforwardly acknowledging the tragedy, apologizing for the city's role and terminating the operator "very early after these events."
The release goes on to say:
The City has responded to this lawsuit by offering to engage in immediate direct discussions and information exchanges to see if this devastating matter can be fairly resolved, without the heartbreaking facts of this case having to be relived and fully aired out in Court by this family. It is hoped that as part of this dialogue, genuine reforms to the habits and customs that contributed to this catastrophe can be achieved, so that no one else is sent into such a "snake pit" in the future.
Look before to see two reports from 9News -- the first about the firing of the operator, the second one broadcast in the immediate aftermath of the homicide -- as well as the complete lawsuit.
More from our Mile High Murder archive: "De'Quan Walker-Smith ID'd as 29th and Franklin homicide victim: Gang-related? (43)"
Get the This Week's Top Stories Newsletter
Every week we collect the latest news, music and arts stories — along with film and food reviews and the best things to do this week — so that you'll never miss Westword's biggest stories.