Lisa Marie Lesyshen enters insanity plea in killing of her nine-year-old son, Asher
Update: Last May, Routt County's Lisa Marie Lesyshen, seen here, was arrested for the murder of Asher Lesyshen-Kirlan, her nine-year-old son. She subsequently appeared in a Denver court for an evidentiary hearing at which it was revealed that the shooting took place after she learned her husband was having an affair. See our previous coverage below. Now, Lesyshen, who's partially paralyzed as a result of a suicide attempt after the killing, has pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity. Details, photos and videos below.
As we've reported, Lisa appeared to dote on Asher, a charming, athletic child who was well known in the Steamboat Springs area (the family lived in the nearby community of Stagecoach) despite his tender years.
For instance, she posted numerous videos of the boy, including this one, which features him singing the song "Twinkle, Twinkle."
But in May, her world came crashing down around her upon stumbling upon an e-mail exchange between her husband, Michael Kirlan, and the woman with whom he was conducting an affair, as he tearfully detailed at the aforementioned hearing, held in November. The session was conducted in Denver because Lisa is in custody here; our jail is reportedly more wheelchair-friendly than the one in Routt County.
Michael Kirlan in court this past November.
At the hearing, Michael confirmed the extramarital relationship to Lisa, prompting a sprawling argument during which she's said to have struck him numerous times and identified him as "the enemy."
Amid the spat, Michael is said to have agreed not to divorce Lisa immediately, so that she could retain her health insurance -- and the next day seemed to move forward in a fairly normal fashion, with her going to work and the family eating together. But around 3 a.m., Michael, who'd been sleeping in the basement, heard loud noises that turned out to be gunfire.
Lisa had purchased a weapon, borrowed ammunition from a neighbor and shot Asher as he slept -- three times in the chest, once in the head.
Lisa Marie Lesyshen at the hearing.
When Kirlan got upstairs, he told the courtroom, he found a dazed Lesyshen emerging from Asher's bedroom. "I don't know what happened in there," she's quoted as telling him before firing off the shot that paralyzed her -- a statement that we suspect will be key in her defense.
Afterward, according to the original arrest warrant on view below, officers found a note next to Asher's bed addressed to Michael. It read "Remember you are responsible for what has happened here and you are the person that caused it." It was signed, "Lisa & Asher."
Lesyshen was back in court yesterday, and as 7News reports, the judge allowed her to plead not guilty by reason of insanity.
What's next? Lesyshen will be examined in the Denver County Jail infirmary by a state-appointed psychiatrist to determine her mental state at the time of the shooting, and whether she understood that she was doing something wrong.
The results of that evaluation are due on May 21, and they'll go a long way toward determining what the future will hold for Lisa Marie Lesyshen.
Look below to see two 7News reports -- the first featuring the latest developments, the second detailing the November hearing. That's followed by the original arrest warrant and our previous coverage.
Update, 6:03 a.m. May 31: More information is emerging about the tragic murder of Routt County's Asher Lesyshen-Kirlan, age nine.
According to local law-enforcement reports, Asher's parents, Lisa Marie Lesyshen and Michael Kirlan, were going through a separation at the time Lisa shot Asher multiple times, killing him.
Afterward, she told Michael to come upstairs and kill her.
As we reported in our original coverage, on view below in its entirety, Michael phoned 911 just before 3 a.m. on Wednesday to say that his son was dead and his wife had a gun at their home, in the community of Stagecoach. Deputies soon discovered Asher's body, as well as Lisa's; she'd shot herself but was still alive.
Here's a photo of Asher with Michael -- part of a gallery mainly consisting of images supplied by readers of Steamboat Today, which is doing the heavy lifting on this story:
Asher with his father, Michael Kirlan.
In the wake of the shooting, Steamboat Today revealed that a post had appeared on Michael's Facebook page alluding to an alleged affair. It was subsequently deleted, raising the possibility that someone other than Michael had shared it. However, neither the woman pictured nor a friend of Michael's would comment on the situation, and the sheriff's office declined to discuss the matter in the context of a possible motive for the shooting.
Now, however, more information is emerging, with Routt County Sheriff Garrett Wiggins holding a press conference and his office releasing a police report obtained by Steamboat Today.
Routt County Sheriff Garrett Wiggins at a press conference.
The report reveals that Michael and Lisa were in the process of separating, although no divorce papers had been filed.
Also: When Michael called for emergency services, he said Asher had been shot but was still breathing -- he subsequently died of multiple gunshot wounds -- and Lisa was upstairs. A quote from the report: "Lisa Lesyshen was telling him to come and kill her."
Asher had been shot in his bedroom; Michael had moved him to the living room. As for Lisa, deputies and Oak Creek police who responded to the scene found her beside her own bed with a single gunshot wound, although three shell casings were in the vicinity of a nearby revolver.
She was conscious and has reportedly confessed to killing Asher. At the hospital, she also asked for an attorney.
Here are two more photos of Asher, followed by our previous coverage, marked by several videos showing the boy during much happier times.
Asher was an active ski jumper.
He also played soccer.
Original post, 6:47 a.m. May 30: The violent death of Routt County's Asher Lesyshen-Kirlan would be tragic under any circumstances. After all, the active nine year old was shot to death by his mother, Lisa Marie Lesyshen, who then turned the gun on herself; she survived, but her current condition hasn't been released.
For those of us who didn't know Asher, though, the loss is amplified by the handful of videos uploaded by Lisa during much happier times. See them and get more details below.
The four clips in Lisa's YouTube playlist (the one we're excluding shows the images sideways) were first shared four years ago. Here's one showing a rambunctious Asher singing "Twinkle, Twinkle."
The other two feature Asher displaying a precocious talent on violin. This one finds him in an informal setting....
...while another clip spotlights his appearance at a recital:
We don't know if Asher continued to fiddle, but as the years went on, he took part in more athletic activities. In its report about Asher's death, Steamboat Today notes that its photo archives include images of him taking part in ski-jumping and bike-racing events. In addition, a photographer captured very recent pics of Asher skateboarding, including the one seen in a screen capture at the top of this post.
What happened? Just shy of 3 a.m. yesterday morning, members of the Routt County Sheriff's Office were called to the Kirlan home, in the community of Stagecoach.
The Kirlan home.
Deputies were met there by Michael Kirlan, Asher's dad and Lisa's husband. Michael told them Asher was dead and his wife was upstairs with a gun. They soon found the boy's body, as well as Lisa, who was transported to an area hospital with what appeared to be a self-inflicted gunshot wound.
As for a potential motive, law enforcers aren't commenting publicly. But Steamboat Today notes that someone appears to have accessed Michael's Facebook page and posted a photo of a woman accompanied by a caption "alleging an affair." The picture was subsequently removed. The paper later determined the identity of the woman in the image and contacted her; she declined comment, as did a friend of Michael's who answered his cell phone when a reporter called.
In the meantime, Asher is being mourned by those who knew and loved him. Our condolences.
Here's a 7News report about the tragedy.
Send your story tips to the author, Michael Roberts.
More from our Mile High Murder archive: "Maria Rodela identified as victim in murder-attempted suicide witnessed by family (76)."
Get the This Week's Top Stories Newsletter
Every week we collect the latest news, music and arts stories — along with film and food reviews and the best things to do this week — so that you’ll never miss Westword's biggest stories.