Live blog: Charlie Brown presents his pot proposal
This morning, Denver City Councilman Charlie Brown presented his proposed ordinance to regulate the city's medical marijuana dispensaries to the council's Safety Committee. We live blogged the hearing; you'll find Brown's proposal at the bottom of this post, with our most recent reports at the top.
11:50 a.m.: Broadwell thinks on-site cultivation will be discussed at the state level. In the meantime, he says, does Denver want to allow marijuana to be grown at a dispensary?
"Always looking at the budget, it could create a licensing fee," Brown says.
Faatz wants to discuss the proposal that dispensary hours be from 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. Brown says he wants to change that, maybe from 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. This, too, will be discussed later.
"And finally," Brown says, in what clearly will not be the final word on this, "the fees." As proposed, the ordinance calls for the same rates as adult cabaret fees: $2,000 for an application fee, $3,000 for an annual fee.
11:40 a.m.: Finally, a visual aid! Jeanne Faatz shows a photograph of someone not only holding a sandwich board advertising a dispensary near Teikyo Heights -- a school -- but offering free samples.
Broadwell points out that under the language of the proposed ordinance, people giving away "free" samples would still be a dispensary. As for the sign, current ordinances already regulate the use of mobile signs in this town -- and there's nothing in the ordinance that would override those.
Nevitt, who needs to leave, acknowledges all of Brown's work and then mentions the one thing that's not in the ordinance: language that makes it clear "we are creating a separate, secure causeway, if you will, for the business of the legal sale of medical marijuana -- one that elevates it above the illegal sale." He'd like to see 24-410 (b) strengthened.
Brown brings up one more key issue: on-site consumption, 24-408. "Mark that with a red pen." Another challenge: cultivation on the premises? "Be ready for that one."
Time is running out on this meeting. Ditto for my battery.
11:30 a.m.: Linkhart calls the meeting back to order and notes the obvious: The committee is not going to get through everything today and will be discussing the issue again on December 16. So he asks council members to mention areas of particular concern.
Brown takes the mike again. "We're on page three of a seven-page proposal," he says. And in the middle of page three is one of the stickiest concepts: requiring that applicants submit an operating plan for their proposed dispensary. And for that matter, he adds, the city will need a plan to handle the applications, so that it does not wind up in the same mess as the state.
Hancock asks for a definition of a "natural person," and the group narrowly avoids another tangential discussion. But Brown presses on to section 24-407.
There's a typo in the draft: Brown and Broadwell are proposing that no matter when the city adopts this ordinance, any dispensary that opens after December 1, 2009 cannot be within 500 feet of any school or child-care establishment, or within 1,000 feet of any other medical marijuana dispensary. "People can continue in this current, unregulated environment doing what they're doing," Broadwell says -- but they're running a risk if they don't follow the proposed rules and then the city adopts them.
11:05 a.m.: The council members have been discussing "good moral character" for fifteen very, very long minutes.
Doug Linkhart suggests a compromise: If a person has a clean record for five years, he or she could be an owner of a dispensary. But are we counting from conviction, or from the day a person has completed a sentence. "I can't believe we're having this discussion," one observer mutters.
Mercifully, the committee members agree to define the "five years" rule later, and the discussion moves on.
Broadwell points out that the only person specifically prohibited from getting a license would be someone who had a medical marijuana dispensary license revoked in the previous twelve months.
Brown notes that an application to operate a dispensary must also include a specific address and proof of ownership or "legal possession" of that address. "It goes to seriousness of the kind of business we're operating," he says.
"The landlord should be aware," Hancock agrees. "This could involve physical requirements."
Nevitt disagrees -- leases are not included with liquor license applications, for example.
To move along the discussion, Linkhart sends this issue, too, to Broadwell for clarification.
Brown calls for a break.
10:40 a.m.: And what kind of scrutiny will the people who own 10 percent of dispensaries be subjected to? State statute says that a liquor-license applicant must be of "good moral character."
But as councilman Chris Nevitt points out, some people who'd like to open a dispensary might have a record for doing something illegal that's now legal -- when Bernard Goetz, the notorious New York subway shooter, could open a gun store in Denver.
Since a few people don't know who Goetz is, Nevitt tries again with a more familiar name: Should Joe Nacchio be allowed to open a dispensary once he gets out of jail?
"Would you say Joe Nacchio is of good moral character?" Judy Montero asks.
No, Nevitt replies. But does Denver really want "good moral character" to be a criteria for a dispensary owner?
10:14 a.m.: Brown moves the conversation along to licensing: He's proposing March 1, 2010 as the day that dispensaries will be required to have licenses from the city -- even if the dispensary was open before March 1.
"If you want to continue operating after that date, you'll need a license," Broadwell says.
To come up with the application procedure, Broadwell and Brown referred to other city licensing procedures. But while liquor-license applications require that anyone who owns at least 10 percent of the business be identified on the application (and subject to a criminal background check), this proposal calls for 20 percent.
After some discussion, the requirement is reduced to 10 percent.
10:00 a.m.: "It's ten o'clock," Charlie Brown says. "Are we ready to deal with this?"
He starts with the preamble (reproduced at the bottom of this post), emphasizing that "compliance with the requirements of this article shall not provide a defense to criminal prosecution under any applicable law."
Seven minutes later, after a clarification from Broadwell, the committee is through the preamble. Next up: how to define a dispensary.
Here, Brown has made a change from his earlier thinking: He is now exempting people who grow and distribute to five or fewer patients from the definition of a dispensary.
"The sort of small, personal operation made legal by Amendment 20," Broadwell adds.
"Is this a home occupation?" asks Raab.
The zoning department will have to look at that, says the zoning administrator, who's called to the table. As it is, you can have a home office and do craft work, even offer a service, but "you can't sell retail."
Linkhart suggests that the city's definition of a "home occupation" is a discussion for another day.
9:45 a.m.: "Some of these are ripped from the headlines," says city attorney David Broadwell, who's worked with Brown on the proposal and now discusses several questions that the Denver proposal is intentionally leaving to the state to answer. The role of doctors, for example. "This ordinance doesn't go there," he notes. Nor does it go into the role of the state registry, what cards look like and how long they take to arrive.
Denver is also leaving the definition of caregivers -- and the possibility of regulating them -- to the state. Will there be a maximum number of patients per caregivers? That came up at a state hearing this summer, Broadwell notes, and it will probably come up again -- but not in the Denver ordinance. Denver isn't getting into grow operations, either. "This is an ordinance about dispensaries per se," he points out.
And there's more than enough to deal with just in this proposed ordinance. David Fine, the Denver city attorney, takes the floor. "We think it's very important legislation, and we want to move with deliberate speed," he says. "But it's important to have discussions with the key stakeholders."
In response to a question from Faatz, he clarifies that Denver will not be waiting for the state to take action. In fact, Fine says, the city just started collecting sales tax from dispensaries yesterday.
9:30 a.m.:This business was once unlawful, Charlie Brown reminds everyone -- but it's legal now, and the city has to deal with it. "In many respects, we are pioneers," he says. "It is important that we get it right." Unlike Los Angeles, for example, which has been trying -- unsuccessfully -- to come up with regulations for close to three years. Brown visited L.A. a few weeks ago, and what he saw there convinced him that Denver can't "dilly dally."
But even while Brown thinks the city needs to deal with the issue, he also believes the city should not address certain issues, which really are the state's responsibility. And they are:
-- legitimacy of doctor-patient relationship -- relationship of doctors to dispensaries -- administration of the state registry and issuance of registry identification cards -- the lawful amount of mmj that may be possessed by patients and caregivers at any one time -- the meaning of "primary caregiver" and the question of whether "caregivers" should be separately tracked and licensed at the state level -- ratio of patients to caregivers -- ratio of caregivers to patients -- grow operations for mmj -- public health regulations for human consumption of mmj -- clarifying state criminal laws to provide clear exceptions for grow-operations and dispensaries from criminal prosecution.
9:23: Councilman Doug Linkhart calls the Safety Committee meeting to order; he's joined at the table by councilmembers Brown, Michael Hancock, Judy Montero, Jeanne Faatz, Paul Lopez, Jeannie Rabb, Marcia Johnson and Peggy Lehman.
A few dozen spectators have gathered for the meeting -- and they're expecting a long one.
Draft Text: Denver Medical Marijuana Dispensary Licensing Ordinance
Amend Chapter 24, D.R.M.C. ("Health and Sanitation") by adding a new Article XI, to read as follows:
Article XI. Medical Marijuana Dispensaries
Sec. 24-401. Purpose and legislative intent. Although the possession and use of marijuana is and remains unlawful under Federal law, Section 14 of Article XVIII of the Colorado Constitution ("Amendment 20") provides an exception to prosecution under state criminal laws when marijuana is possessed and used for medicinal purposes by a patient who has been diagnosed with a debilitating medical condition and by the patient's primary caregivers. Amendment 20 does not, however, contain any provision for the lawful sale or distribution of marijuana to patients and, to date, the State of Colorado has failed to adopt laws or regulations to clearly explain how and whether marijuana may be lawfully sold or otherwise distributed to patients. As a result of this ambiguity in the State law, unregulated medical marijuana dispensaries have proliferated in Denver and elsewhere in Colorado. The purpose of this Article is to license and regulate medical marijuana dispensaries in the interest of public health, safety and general welfare. In particular, this Article in intended to regulate the sale and distribution of marijuana in the interest of patients who qualify to obtain, possess and use marijuana for medical purposes under Amendment 20, while promoting compliance with other state laws that prohibit trafficking in marijuana for non-medical purposes. Nothing in this article is intended to promote or condone the sale, distribution, possession or use of marijuana in violation of any applicable law. Compliance with the requirements of this article shall not provide a defense to criminal prosecution under any applicable law. Persons who cultivate, possess, sell, distribute, purchase, or use marijuana, whether for medical or non-medical purposes, do so at their own risk of prosecution under any applicable federal, state or local law.
Sec. 24-402. Definitions.
The following words and phrases, when used in this article, shall have the meanings respectively assigned to them:
(1) Director means the director of the department of excise and licenses, or the director's duly authorized representative.
(2) Marijuana shall have the same meaning as is set forth in section 38-175 (c).
(3) Medical Marijuana dispensary means a business that sells or otherwise distributes marijuana through one or more primary care-givers to six (6) or more patients for medical use, along with any cultivation of marijuana associated with such sale or distribution. The term "medical marijuana dispensary" shall not include any person or entity that distributes marijuana for medical use exclusively to five (5) or fewer patients, and shall not include the private possession and medical use of marijuana by an individual patient to the extent permitted by Article XVIII, Section 14 of the Colorado Constitution and any other applicable state law or regulation.
(4) Medical use shall have the same meaning as is set forth in Article XVIII, Section 14(1)(b) of the Colorado Constitution, or as may be more fully defined in any applicable state law or regulation.
(5) Patient shall have the same meaning as is set forth in Article XVIII, Section 14(1)(d) of the Colorado Constitution, or as may be more fully defined in any applicable state law or regulation.
(6) Primary care-giver shall have the same meaning as is set forth in Article XVIII, Section 14(1)(f) of the Colorado Constitution, or as may be more fully defined in any applicable state law or regulation.
(7) School or child care establishment means any public or private school meeting all requirements of the compulsory education laws of the state and providing instruction to students in kindergarten through grade twelve; any public or private schools or pre-schools that provide preparatory schooling for children of any age younger than the state age of mandatory attendance; or any child care establishment as defined by and regulated under Chapter 11 of this Code.
Sec. 24-403. License Required.
(a) On and after [March, 1, 2010] it shall be unlawful for any person to sell or otherwise distribute any marijuana for medical use without obtaining a license to operate as a medical marijuana dispensary pursuant to the requirements of this article. This licensing requirement shall apply regardless of whether or not a medical marijuana dispensary has commenced operation prior to said date.
(b) The license requirement set forth in this article shall be in addition to, and not in lieu of, any other licensing and permitting requirements imposed by any other federal, state, or city law including, by way of example, a retail sales tax license, a retail food establishment license if applicable, any applicable zoning or building permit, and an alarm system permit.
Sec. 24-404. General licensing procedures.
Except as otherwise specifically provided in this article, the general procedures and requirements for issuance and administration of licenses by the director, as more fully set forth in Article I of Chapter 32, shall apply to medical marijuana dispensary licenses. To the extent there is any conflict between the provisions of this article and Article I of Chapter 23, the provisions of this article shall control.
Sec. 24-405. Application.
(a) Application for a medical marijuana dispensary license shall be made to the director upon forms provided by the director for that purpose. In addition to the information required by Chapter 32 of this Code, the application shall include the following information:
(1) Name and address of the owner or owners of the medical marijuana dispensary in whose name the license is proposed to be issued.
(2) If the owner is a corporation, the name and address of any officer or director of the corporation, and of any person holding twenty percent (20%) or more of the issued and outstanding capital stock of the corporation.
(3) If the owner is a partnership, association or company, the name and address of any member holding twenty percent (20%) or more of the interest therein.
(4) Name and address of any manager or managers of the medical marijuana dispensary, if the manager is proposed to be someone other than the owner. The application shall also contain 24-hour contact information for the manager or managers of the licensed premises which shall be made available to the general public in order to provide a prompt response to public questions and concerns about the operation of the licensed premises.
(5) A statement of whether or not any of the foregoing persons have:
a. Been denied an application for a medical marijuana dispensary license pursuant to this article of any similar state or local licensing law, or had such a license suspended or revoked. b. Been convicted of a felony, or of violating any other federal, state or local law governing the manufacture, distribution, possession or use of controlled substances [Subject to further discussion of convictions that will disqualify a licensee.]
(6) Proof of ownership or legal possession of the licensed premises for the term of the proposed license. If the licensed premises will be leased, the application shall include written consent by the owner of the property to the licensing of the premises for a medical marijuana dispensary.
(7) An operating plan for the proposed medical marijuana dispensary including the following information:
b. A narrative description of the ownership and organizational structure of the medical marijuana dispensary. c. A description of the products and services to be provided by the medical marijuana dispensary, including an indication of whether or not the dispensary proposed to engage in the retail sale of food for human consumption. d. A projection of the number of patients to be served by the primary care-givers in the medical marijuana dispensary. e. A floor plan, drawn to scale, showing the layout of the medical marijuana dispensary and the principle uses of the floor area depicted therein. f. A security plan indicating how the applicant intends to comply with the requirements of section 24-408 (d).
(8) An area map, drawn to scale, indicating, within a radius of one-quarter mile from the boundaries of the property upon which the medical marijuana dispensary is located, the proximity of the property to any school or child care establishment, to any other medical marijuana dispensary, or to any residential zone district.
(b) Any application for a medical marijuana dispensary permit shall be accompanied by the application fee, criminal background check fee, and annual fee as required by section 32-93.
(c) Upon receipt of an application for a medical marijuana dispensary license, the director shall circulate the application to the Department of Community Planning and Development, the Department of Finance, the Department of Environmental Health, the Denver Police Department, and the Denver Fire Department to determine whether the proposed dispensary is in full compliance with any and all laws, rule and regulations administered by the respective departments.
(d) The director shall perform a criminal background investigation for each applicant or manager to determine compliance with section 24-406.
(e) The director shall perform an inspection of the proposed licensed premises to determine compliance with any applicable requirement of this article.
(f) The director shall deny any application for a license that is not in full compliance with this article, any other applicable city law or regulation, or any state law or regulation governing medical marijuana dispensaries. The director shall also deny any application that contains any false or incomplete information.
24-406. Persons prohibited as licensees and managers.
(a) No license provided by this article shall be issued or held by:
(1) Any person who, in the immediately proceeding twelve months had a medical marijuana dispensary license revoked by the city.
(2) Any person who has been convicted of a [Subject to further discussion of the type of criminal convictions that would disqualify a licensee.] with this prohibition applying to:
a. Any owner who is a natural person.
b. If the owner is a corporation, any officer or director of the corporation, and any person holding twenty percent (20%) or more of the issued and outstanding capital stock of the corporation.
c. If the owner is a partnership, association or company, any member holding twenty percent (20%) or more of the interest therein.
(b) No licensed premises shall be managed by any person who has been convicted of a [Subject to further discussion of the type of criminal convictions that would disqualify a manager.]
24-407. Prohibited locations.
(a) All medical marijuana dispensary licenses shall be issued for a specific fixed location which shall be considered the licensed premises. All sales or distribution of medical marijuana shall be made directly by a primary care-giver to a patient upon the licensed premises, or via personal delivery of the medical marijuana by the primary care-giver from the licensed premises to the patient at the patient's residence.
(b) No medical marijuana dispensary license shall be issued for the following locations:
(1) In any residential zone district as defined by the zoning code of the city, or in any other location where retail sales are prohibited by the zoning code.
(2) For any medical marijuana dispensary that commenced operation on or after December 1, 2010, within five hundred (500) feet of any school or child care establishment, with the distance being measured in a straight line from the nearest point on the building containing the dispensary to the nearest point on the building containing the school or child care establishment.
(3) For any medical marijuana dispensary that commenced operation on or after December 1 2010, within one thousand (1,000) feet of any other medical marijuana dispensary, with the distance being measured from the nearest point on the building containing the dispensary to the nearest point on the building containing the other dispensary.
24-408. Requirements related to licensed premises.
(a) No marijuana shall be smoked, eaten or otherwise consumed or ingested on the licensed premises.
(b) No person under eighteen years of age shall be permitted on the licensed premises, unless the person has been qualified to possess marijuana for medical use in accordance with Article XVIII, Section 14 (6) of the Colorado Constitution and the person is accompanied by a parent.
(c) The name and contact information for the owner or owners and any manager of the medical marijuana dispensary shall be conspicuously posted in the dispensary.
(d) Any and all cultivation, processing, storage, display, sales or other distribution of marijuana shall occur within an enclosed building and shall not be visible from the exterior of the building.
(e) No licensed premises shall be managed by any person other than the owner or the manager listed on the application for the license.
(f) The medical marijuana dispensary shall be closed to the public, and no sale or other distribution of marijuana shall occur upon the licensed premises or via delivery from the licensed premises between the hours of 11 p.m. and 11 a.m.
(g) The licensed premises shall be monitored and secured 24-hours per day including, at a minimum, the following security measures:
(1) Extra security for window, doors and any other point of ingress to prevent unauthorized entry, which may include extra locking devices, bars, or similar measures.
(2) Installation and use of security cameras to monitor all areas of the licensed premises where persons may gain or attempt to gain access to marijuana or cash maintained by the medical marijuana dispensary. Recordings from security cameras shall be maintained for a minimum of seventy-two hours in a secure off-site location. (3) Installation and use of a safe for overnight storage of any processed marijuana, cash, and patient records maintained on the licensed premises.
(4) Installation of a monitored user alarm system pursuant to Division 2 of Article IV of Chapter 42 of this Code.
(h) Cultivation and processing of marijuana upon the licensed premises shall be permitted only when the premises are equipped with a ventilation system that filters out the odors of the marijuana so it is not detectable from the exterior of the building or from any adjoining premises. Approval of such a system from the building department is required prior to the cultivation or processing of marijuana beginning on the licensed premises.
24-409. Requirements related to public health and labeling.
(a) All marijuana sold or otherwise distributed by the licensee shall be packaged and labeled in a manner that indicates the quantity and type of marijuana dispensed, and advises the purchaser that the marijuana is intended for use solely by the patient to whom it is sold, and that any re-sale or re-distribution of the marijuana to any third person is a criminal violation.
(b) Any licensee selling marijuana in the form of prepared food shall be required to obtain a retail food establishment license issued by the Department of Environmental Health in accordance with Article III of Chapter 23 of this Code. The licensee shall comply with any and all applicable state and local health regulations related to the preparation, labeling, and sale of prepared food items.
24-410. Compliance with state law.
(a) To the extent the state has adopted or adopts in the future any additional or stricter law or regulation governing the sale or distribution of marijuana for medical purposes, the additional or stricter regulation shall control the establishment or operation of any medical marijuana dispensary in the city. Compliance with any applicable state law or regulation shall be deemed an additional requirement for issuance or denial of any license under this article, and non-compliance with any applicable state law or regulation shall be grounds for revocation of any license issued hereunder.
(b) Any medical marijuana dispensary licensed pursuant to this article, may be required to prove, upon demand by the director or by law enforcement, that the source and quantity of any marijuana found upon the licensed premises is in full compliance with any applicable state law or regulation.
(c) If the state prohibits the sale or other distribution of marijuana through medical marijuana dispensaries, any license issued pursuant to this article shall be deemed to be immediately revoked by operation of law, with no ground for appeal or other redress on behalf of the licensee.
(d) The issuance of any license pursuant to this article shall not be deemed to create an exception, defense, or immunity to any person in regard to any potential criminal liability the person may have for the cultivation, possession, sale, distribution, or use of marijuana.
Amend Article II of Chapter 32 concerning License Fees by adding a new section 32-93, to read as follows:
Sec. 32-93. Medical marijuana dispensaries.
Application and license fees for medical marijuana dispensaries are as follows:
(1) Application fee . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $2,000 (2) Criminal background check fee, per person checked . . . . . Actual costs (3) License fee, per year . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $3,000
Get the Marijuana Newsletter
Stay informed of the latest marijuana news and views with updates about dispensaries, strains, products, changes to the law, and special offers in your area.