Molly Midyette: Court of Appeals dismissal part of Molly's plan, says lawyer
As described in "Bedtime Story," Molly Midyette was sentenced to sixteen years for the death of her infant son, Jason, in one of the most sensational Boulder cases in years -- something she now says was unfair because her ex-husband Alex Midyette and his powerful family allegedly sabotaged her defense to help Alex. Now the Colorado Court of Appeals has dismissed an appeal Molly filed over her case -- something Molly's lawyer Alison Ruttenberg says is all part of the plan.
Ruttenberg and co-council Tom Carberry, after all, were the ones who asked for the dismissal back in March. That's because the Court of Appeals had ruled that Molly's appeal to their court would have to be considered in its entirety before her lawyers could try a different tact - requesting a whole new trial in district court.
After that decision, filing to dismiss the appeal made sense, says Ruttenberg, because as she puts it, "There was nothing to appeal." That's because Molly's original criminal attorney, hotshot defense lawyer Craig Truman, hardly objected during her trial at all, meaning there were few issues preserved from the trial they could use in the appeal. There's also the matter that the appeal was largely based on whether or not Paul McCormick, Alex's lawyer, had unfairly meddled in Molly's case -- and Molly's lawyers say there was a lot more wrong with Molly's trial than just that.
Hence Molly and her lawyer's decision to do away with the appeal altogether and focus on arguing in Boulder County district court that Molly deserves a new trial because, for many reasons, she didn't receive fair representation the first time around. Next month, the Boulder district judge on the case will hold a status conference on the matter to decide when to schedule lengthy evidentiary hearings on the matter, says Ruttenberg. That's also when the Boulder District Attorney's office will disclose whether it will withdraw from the case and ask for a special prosecutor -- something Ruttenberg says she's sure it will, because "they are too intimately involved in the case as witnesses."
At the end of the evidentiary hearings, the court will decide whether or not Molly deserves another day in court -- something that the losing party in the matter is likely to take to the Colorado Court of Appeals. All in all, Ruttenberg says it will likely be another two years until Molly actually gets a new trial, if she scores one at all. By that point, she will likely already be eligible for Community Corrections.
To Molly, that doesn't matter, says Ruttenberg: "She is going to fight this."
More from our Follow That Story archive: "Molly Midyette, sentenced to 16 years for her son Jason's death, speaks out (VIDEO)"
Get the This Week's Top Stories Newsletter
Every week we collect the latest news, music and arts stories — along with film and food reviews and the best things to do this week — so that you’ll never miss Westword's biggest stories.