There is no end to the dog puns that can and have been made about Border Collie-mix Shelby's appointment as the leader of Occupy Denver's leaderless movement. Westword will be doggone if we haven't heard the full range of them since we announced her term exactly two weeks ago. But this weekend brought in a new batch of cheap shots heard round the world on NPR. Culled from all the feedback over the past fourteen days is an important question: Has Shelby become a martyr or a mockery?
Although the camps are split on the issue (especially in Westword's comments section), Shelby has certainly become more decorated as she embraces her turn in office. Saturday rallies now find the three-and-a-half-year-old fronting the pack in a personalized blue cape with the red Superman "S" logo (Super Shelby?), and her speckled face has made it to both Gawker and the Rachel Maddow Show, among other national media outlets.
Saturday's episode of NPR's Peter Sagal and Carl Kasell-hosted news game show Wait Wait... Don't Tell Me! featured panelists Adam Felber, Faith Salie and Roy Blount, Jr. -- and Shelby, who was referenced on national airwaves (and in podcast form) as the answer to a political quiz question.
"One of the characteristics of the Occupy Wall Street movement is that they refuse to elect leaders, but the Occupy Denver people went ahead and elected who to be their leader this week?... This leader thinks conditions for the 99 percent are "'ruff!'"
The answer that followed was accompanied by a round of jokes aimed at an action many outside of Denver see as a stunt. Last night, in fact, a handful of Occupy Denver protesters argued about whether Shelby's election, intended as a pointed (if ironic) statement about suggestions that the group choose a leader in order to be taken more seriously, risked becoming a jumping-the-shark moment. While a large number of local occupiers supports the decision, some say it backfired -- and the NPR bit may be interpreted as evidence that's the case. At one point, for instance, a commentator announces that "she's changed the focus from income inequality more towards sniffing crotches and rolling around in garbage."
The discussion of Shelby continues with, "It turned out to be sort of their downfall, because when police moved in, as they did in many cities this week, to shut down the protests and clean up the parks, instead of using armed force, like they did in New York, in Denver all they had to do was throw a stick outside the park and the leader took off after her. Everybody went after her, and that was it."
If you like this story, consider signing up for our email newsletters.
SHOW ME HOW
To listen to the entire segment, click below.
More from our Occupy Denver archive: "Occupy Denver: David Lane on city collusion denial, injunction over honks, donations & more."