Sources: Bachelor Ben Higgins's Political Run Killed Because He's a Republican

A photo of Ben Higgins and his fiancee, Lauren Bushnell, from his Instagram account. Additional images and more below.
A photo of Ben Higgins and his fiancee, Lauren Bushnell, from his Instagram account. Additional images and more below.

Denver's Ben Higgins, who starred in the most recent season of ABC's The Bachelor, was poised to take a leap into Colorado politics. But after announcing his intentions, he withdrew his candidacy. Sources tell us he did so because of pressure from TV executives associated with the reality program, who were so terrified that his decision to run as a Republican would cause him to be associated with the GOP and its current standard bearer, Donald Trump, that they threatened to kill a new show featuring him, as well as block his wedding.

Higgins was rejected as a suitor on The Bachelorette in 2015. But he made such an impression on viewers that he was chosen to become the next Bachelor — and from all appearances, he actually found love on the show. He's engaged to marry Lauren Bushnell in a ceremony expected to be at the center of a new reality program slated to air on the cable channel Freeform (formerly ABC Family) in the coming months. Its title: Ben and Lauren: Happily Ever After.

Not so happy was the end of Higgins's planned race for the Colorado legislature in House District 4, currently represented by Representative Dan Pabon, who had been a rising star in the state's Democratic Party until he was busted for driving under the influence in March. Pabon's fortunes took another hit last week with the release of body camera footage that showed him apparently trying to use his influence to squirm out of an arrest.

But last Friday, after Higgins was chosen to challenge Pabon by the vacancy committee of the Colorado Republican Party and filed official paperwork to formalize his candidacy, he abruptly pulled the plug on the campaign. A statement released under the auspices of Disney, the parent company of ABC, maintains that Higgins was unable to move forward "due to unforeseen circumstances."

According to Steve House, chairman of the Colorado Republican Committee, those circumstances had plenty to do with his party affiliation. "I do not believe that he would have been asked to step out of this race if he were a Democrat," House maintains.

A knowledgeable source agrees with House and provides much more background on the forces brought to bear on Higgins, who could not be reached for comment. Our source says Higgins was told that if he insisted on challenging Pabon, Ben and Lauren: Happily Ever After would be canceled and he would not be able to marry Bushnell for two years — because the combination of ABC, Disney and Warner Horizon, the company that produces The Bachelor and The Bachelorette, owns the rights to his wedding.

Dan Pabon.
Dan Pabon.
Denver District Attorney's Office

Ordinarily, Pabon, who has not responded to interview requests from Westword (neither has Rick Palacio, chairman of the Colorado Democratic Party), would have almost certainly cruised to reelection in District 4. As House acknowledges, any challenger "would have been a significant long shot against a Democrat incumbent in a district that's more Democrat than Republican." But everything changed around 11:30 p.m. on March 17, when Pabon's car was stopped by authorities and he registered just over the legal intoxication limit.

On July 19, the Denver District Attorney's Office revealed that Pabon had pleaded guilty to misdemeanor DUI. He was sentenced to one year of probation and ordered to attend a victim impact panel and an alcohol education and treatment class, undergo monitored sobriety, perform 56 hours of community service and pay court costs and fees of $1,303.

But that wasn't the end of the story. Pabon's arrest was captured in body-camera footage released around the time of his sentencing, and as seen in a 7News report on view below,  Pabon asked the arresting officer, "Can you put a call into your supervisor or the city attorney?"

"They will be notified because of who you are," the officer replied.

"Is there any way we can avoid this possibility?" Pabon wanted to know. "I mean, I know you've got…"

"I cannot, no," the officer told him, prompting Pabon to say, "This is going to change my life right now."

Another portrait of Ben Higgins and Lauren Bushnell.
Another portrait of Ben Higgins and Lauren Bushnell.

Pabon's downturn opened up an opportunity for Higgins, who makes a modest salary working for the software company Talisys. After his season on The Bachelor concluded, our source says, network personnel asked Higgins what he would like to do next. His response: He's always wanted to get into public service and run for office.

This dream didn't immediately set off alarms among The Bachelor's brain trust, and neither did his party affiliation. According to our source, a political run for Pabon's seat seemed to producers like a great potential story line for Ben and Lauren: Happily Ever After, which was already in the planning stages. And while some of those involved would have preferred that Higgins (a registered Republican since October 2014) run as an independent, no one seemed to regard his unwillingness to do so as a deal breaker.

Neither, we're told, were major anxieties spawned by the prospect of having to provide equal time to Pabon. The equal-time rule only pertains to broadcast TV, not cable — and besides, Pabon would have been offered the chance to appear on Happily Ever After if he wished. In addition, members of Higgins's team went through the legal implications of the show and concluded that there were no significant obstacles.

House confirms that the folks behind the show weren't blindsided by Higgins's plan. "They knew all along," he says. "Ben had checked with them ahead of time."

On Instagram, Higgins wrote of Bushnell, "She will always be getting my rose."
On Instagram, Higgins wrote of Bushnell, "She will always be getting my rose."

At first, our source says, the political run was seen as the spine of the show — but after further consideration, producers decided to make it merely an element of the narrative, which would otherwise concentrate on the run-up to the wedding.

Upcoming Events

In the days before the July 18 start of the Republican National Convention in Cleveland, all systems were go for the Higgins race. But thanks to the dark tone of that event — plenty of commentators called Donald Trump's acceptance speech "apocalyptic" — the momentum was reversed. After the RNC concluded, our source says, producers were worried about viewers connecting Higgins and Trump, albeit without explicitly saying so. Instead, they expressed concern that the Democratic Party would file a lawsuit in an effort to stop the show — and even though Higgins's supporters were confident such a gambit would be unsuccessful, the network suits said they didn't want to risk the negative publicity.

Potential options included moving the show's debut to January, after the election was over. But in the end, Happily Ever After representatives decided that if Higgins ran, the show was history. Our source says he was initially willing to bow out of the program, even though it would have meant a tremendous financial hit; not only would he lose the money he was slated to receive for Happily Ever After, but he'd also forfeit cash for any cameos on other ABC shows. (Even his appearance on a July 31 episode of Celebrity Family Feud would have been impacted.) But what really convinced him to drop his challenge to Pabon was learning that he couldn't marry Bushnell for two years because of the wedding-rights issue. Even if they were married by a Justice of the Peace, the couple might have been considered to be in violation of the contract if anyone gave them a wedding gift.

As such, Higgins signed on to a Disney-vetted statement that reads:

I regret that I must withdraw my candidacy. Despite my best efforts to pursue this opportunity in good faith, I recently received information that has made such a pursuit unworkable. Due to unforeseen circumstances, I will not be able to move forward as a candidate. I find solace in knowing that our intentions and actions have been fair and sincere. I entered into this endeavor wanting to bring positive change to my community, and it is with that same spirit that I will move forward, albeit on a different path.

Also weighing in was Dustin Olson, Higgins's campaign consultant. Olson declined to comment for this story beyond the following statement:

Ben and our team are incredibly disappointed. Ben had worked to develop a strong message and solutions to make a big difference to people in his community, including solutions for affordable housing, protecting the Taxpayer Bill of Rights, defending small businesses, and expanding personal liberty and freedom. Between support from our friends in the Republican Party, building a talented campaign team, and lining up financial support, we were ready to kick off the campaign with huge announcement rally next week. Mostly we are disappointed with the situation because the people who live in House District 4 deserve much better representation. The abuse of power and rank hypocrisy demonstrated by Dan Pabon in his disturbing arrest video, clearly demonstrates Pabon lacks the sound judgment to continue serving in an office of public trust. We agree with the Denver Post that Pabon should do the honorable thing and resign. Sadly, his replacement can't be Ben Higgins.

Just as frustrated by this turn of events is GOP chairman House, who puts the blame for Higgins's aborted candidacy squarely on the network — and gives it an ideological spin.

"The ABC media arm is much like a lot of media arms. They're more liberal than conservative," he says. "I don't think they like the idea of one of their guys getting in and becoming a Republican legislator, because I think he would have won the race."

Bushnell, Higgins and a friend.
Bushnell, Higgins and a friend.

Indeed, House believes that the idea of Higgins running and losing was more attractive to network types than was the prospect of victory.

"As Pabon's problems became more clear, I think ABC began to think it would no longer be tolerable, because Ben might actually get into the state House and start legislating on a conservative basis," House maintains. "It's really disappointing that he doesn't have that opportunity now."

Higgins's withdrawal leaves the Republicans without a District 4 hopeful — but given Pabon's problems, a win isn't out of the question.

In House's view, "Pabon did something that is a complete breach of the public trust, and I think he needs to do the right thing as a legislator. People are calling for his resignation, and I think it's probably appropriate. When you start leveraging your status in the government to try to deal with a crime, that's way over the line."

In the meantime, House and company are actively recruiting candidates to take on Pabon. He expects the process to be completed by the end of the first week in August.

Shooting for Ben and Lauren: Happily Ever After is already under way. Here's the 7News report featuring the Pabon video.


Upcoming Events

From Our Sponsors


Sponsor Content

Newsletters

All-access pass to the top stories, events and offers around town.

  • Top Stories
    Send:

Newsletters

All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >