Like all purveyors of great barbecue, Hoss Orwat is a renaissance man, a fine storyteller and a little bit goofy in the head. I've never known a good pit man who didn't come to barbecue sideways — who didn't sneak up on it or stumble into it or (in the case of the generational genius) flee from it before coming back like a chastened lover caught hound-dogging. I've known smokers who were once bankers or computer programmers or rich layabouts. I've known guys who've done barbecue illegally because, when given a choice between ribs and John Law, the ribs are gonna win every time. And I've known classically trained chefs who've thrown it all away on a couple of box smokers and the tinny smell of pork blood — because even amid cooks, the great pit men are a class apart, outlaws among outlaws.
And Hoss is one of them. We talked twice last week, and we talked for a long time — the conversation looping and referential, full of backtracks and weird asides. Hoss is full of strange enthusiasms and digressions and bluster, and when he talks about food he's talking about history and culture, too. He can make those links between grub and jazz, between pork shoulder and economics. And he's acquainted with James Carville, the Democratic strategist turned political analyst who knows a thing or two about good eats.
Like me, Hoss was born and raised in Upstate New York. When I left, it was to learn about Mexican and Cuban food and to get the hell away from the snow. When Hoss left, it was to get a master's degree in history focusing on Southern culture and politics. "I was good, you know?" he said. "Me and one of my professors would sit around eating hush puppies and talking about Faulkner." Hush puppies and drinks, sometimes. Sometimes drinks and a little bit of barbecue. When Hoss was working on his thesis, he'd pull into some town to research what had happened there politically — and inevitably, he'd end up eating barbecue with the mayor and getting saucy fingerprints all over his books. It was the best kind of education, because in great joints across the country, politics and food have always been interlinked — one humping the leg of the other. If you want to be in politics up north, you're going to spend a lot of time pressing the flesh and getting yelled at in diners. You want to do the same thing down south, you'd better love you some barbecue.
Once Hoss finished his degree, he took his sheepskin on the road with the Democratic National Committee. "I was just a hack," he said, selling himself a little short. What he was was a serious hack — a speechwriter for local, state and national races and one of the foot soldiers in the Clinton/Gore campaign. Which is how we got to talking about Carville and his 1996 book We're Right, They're Wrong, which, in addition to being an excellent read and a good source of (somewhat dated) material with which to taunt and pummel Republicans, also contains a wicked recipe for backyard-picnic potato salad and musings about politicians and food.
"One of my wife's friends was going to have a huge barbecue for the Fourth of July," Carville writes. "Sure, it was going to be a chest-thumping, live-free-or-die kind of Republican affair, but I have to admit it sounded great...[because] based on prior experience, I knew the food was going to be first rate. I will admit it: Republican gatherings always have better food than Democratic ones. Only good thing about a Republican party is the food."
After a few years of speechwriting and spinning, Hoss was fed up with politics. "I didn't have the stomach for it," he said, so he did the next logical thing: He wrote a novel. And then he did what many would-be writers end up doing: He tended bar. By now he was living in Colorado, working at the Sports Page in Louisville, where he did barbecue two nights a week. Then he drifted to New Castle, where he lived in a camper-top next to a bowling alley and cooked more barbecue. "It's like Charlie Parker said," Hoss explained. "You have all these things, all this life, all these troubles, and it all comes out of your horn. Well, it's the same thing with everything, whatever you're passionate about."
Actually, what Parker said was, "If you don't live it, it won't come out of your horn," but I understood what Hoss was getting at. He'd done a lot, seen a lot, experienced a lot. And now, what was coming out of his horn was barbecue — America's greatest cuisine and best expression of her collective soul.
Hoss's various travels have influenced his barbecue — he talked about the Lexington pit in his kitchen, the delicious heresy of closed-pit-smoking his Texas brisket, how economics and the historic movement of Carolina pig farmers created my favorite barbecue style, Carolina tidewater, practiced in maybe a dozen towns sitting right on the sand — but ultimately, his barbecue is his own. He opened a restaurant in Boulder and closed it. Opened another in Snowmass, then sold it. Finally, on December 11, 2006, he opened Big Hoss Bar-B-Q on Tennyson Street thinking that this was it: the culmination.
And he was right.
"I'm doing barbecue fusion," he said. "I mean, I think, right? I didn't think barbecue was getting the respect it deserves, so I wanted to put Denver on the barbecue map. And I gotta tell you, this has been great. It's all been great. Now, in one day, I can make people happier than I could in a whole campaign."
Man-flirting? I was sitting at Big Hoss's bar two weeks ago, working my way through a plate of ribs, when the sag-eyed and slurring Dave Matthews-looking dipshit sitting close to me starts talking to the bartender.
"Tell him I got him," Dave Matthews says. "He got me, then I got him, then he got me another, so buy him a drink. Make sure he knows where it's coming from, okay?" He half-stands, reaches into his pocket and pulls out a crumpled wad of bills, scattering them on the bar before groping for the Jäger depth charge in front of him. He manages to get his hand around it on the third try, lifts it up and uses it to salute this guy at the other end of the bar who looks kinda like Papa Smurf if Papa Smurf were six feet tall and a former telemark skier or high-mountain drug runner.
Dave Matthews drinks. Papa Smurf laughs. Dave Matthews points down the bar with both hands, giving Papa Smurf the whole "you-da-man" white-guy panoply of hand signals: the two-finger point, the thumbs-up, the raise-the-roof. Then he sits. Falls, really. But his khakis connect with the bar stool, so I guess it counts as sitting.
"It's nothin'," Dave Matthews says to no one in particular, seeing as how the bartender has gone down to the other end of the bar and I don't care. "Just a little bit of man-flirting."
Man-flirting? This is what we've been reduced to?
I've got no problem with out-and-out homosexuality. Without it, half the country's restaurants would be without floor staffs and my friend Big Gay Steve would have no one to stick his dick in. Also, I've got no problem with the long and noble tradition of guys buying other guys drinks at the bar. Buying drinks for strangers marks you as a social fellow, as someone I want to be close to in case you should feel the urge to put more drinks on your tab.
But since I'm fairly sure that neither Dave Matthews nor Papa Smurf were trying to get in each other's pants, I was baffled by this blatant violation of bar-room drinks-buying decorum and tempted to have a little talk with Dave Matthews, to explain that when another man buys you a drink, the correct response is simply to pick it up and raise it gently in your benefactor's direction in a discreet and silent salute to his kindness and goodwill. Then, after a period of not more than ten minutes has passed, you should inquire of the bartender as to whether she thinks the kind gentleman might want another drink of his own. You DO NOT choose his drink for him. You DO NOT assume that he wants another.
Once a single round of drinks has been exchanged, you have two options. Option one: If either party is interested, he may approach the other guy and strike up a conversation. Some of my best, most enduring friendships have begun exactly this way. (As a matter of fact, that's kind of how I met Big Gay Steve — though at the time, he was Little Still-in-the-Closet Steve.) Also, one of the worst fights I ever got in — but that's another story.
Option two: Do nothing. Drinks have been exchanged, quiet toasts have been raised, and now both men are free to go about their business unmolested.
No matter which option you choose, absolutely no cross-bar sign language should ever be attempted. By anyone. Especially if you look like Dave Matthews and (as I realized after watching subsequent exchanges) are being completely fucked with by Papa Smurf because he keeps sending you Jäger shots dropped in rocks glasses full of beer while he is drinking civilized glasses of call whiskey on your tab.
Let's be careful out there.
Get the Food & Drink Newsletter
Our weekly guide to Denver dining includes food news and reviews, as well as dining events and interviews with chefs and restaurant owners.