If you're a relative newcomer -- i.e., not someone with a "Native" sticker on the bumper -- you might be surprised to hear that Highland wasn't always a synonym for "hot, new restaurant." Back in the day, the area once known as Little Italy was full of family-owned restaurants dishing up spaghetti and meatballs, chicken marsala and spumoni to northwest Denver's Italian population -- and anyone else with a car and an appetite. See also: - Photos: Last supper at Pagliacci's - Longo's Subway Tavern reaches the end of the line - Lechuga's in northwest Denver is famous for its canolis - Patsy's Italian Restaurant has a rich, colorful, unbeatable history
Then in August, Pagliacci's Italian Restaurant closed after almost seventy years, breaking the hearts of generations of diners who'd swooned over its seven-layer lasagna and other traditional fare. Barely a month later, mourning continued as Longo's Subway Tavern, purported to be the first place in Colorado to serve pizza, shuttered after more than a half-century.
Now, it seems, Denver's original red-sauce institutions can be counted on one hand. There's Patsy's Italian Restaurant, which opened in 1921 and is now owned by a relative of the founder; Carl's Pizza; Lechuga's Italian Restaurant, home of the famous meat canoli; and Carbone's Italian Sausage Deli, which is part-market, part-sandwich shop. Outside city limits, there's Dino's Italian Food in Lakewood and Romano's Italian Restaurant in Littleton.
And then there's Gaetano's. After closing for renovations this summer, the 65-year-old restaurant -- once owned by one of Denver's old crime families, the Smaldones, now owned by another family altogether, BW Holdings, a joint venture of the Wynkoop group and Breckenridge Brewery -- reopened this fall with a new vibe and a new menu.
If you like this story, consider signing up for our email newsletters.
SHOW ME HOW
You have successfully signed up for your selected newsletter(s) - please keep an eye on your mailbox, we're movin' in!
Is a meal at Gaetano's still an offer you can't refuse? Find out tomorrow when this week's review is posted here. And in the meantime, if you know of other old-school Italian joints around town, let us know in the comments section below.