Six Really Old, Old-School Red-Sauce Italian Joints in Metro Denver

Old-school Italian still survives in Denver.EXPAND
Old-school Italian still survives in Denver.
Danielle Lirette

Carl's Pizza, which is still holding down the same corner on West 38th Avenue where it's been for 63 years, is one of the few remaining Italian eateries in metro Denver that have made it past the half-century mark at their original location. (Here's our full story of how Carl's got its start.) Romano's Italian Restaurant will celebrate its fiftieth birthday in 2017; Three Sons opened in Sunnyside more than five decades ago, but numerous moves (it's now at 4805 West 64th Avenue in Arvada) and an ownership change give it only tenuous links to the past. And while Carbone's,  which cranked out sausage and hot Italian sandwiches for years before closing in 2013,  is back; it's now serving those famous sandwiches from inside the new Monkey Barrel at 4401 Tejon Street. There are at least six more red-sauce joints that have made it past fifty, though, and continue to turn out old-school Italian in the same spot where they first stirred up that red sauce.

The Blue Parrot stands at the corner of Pine and Main streets in LouisvilleEXPAND
The Blue Parrot stands at the corner of Pine and Main streets in Louisville
The Blue Parrot

The Blue Parrot Restaurant
640 Main Street, Louisville
303-666-0677

Opened in 1919, the Blue Parrot is the oldest continually operating family-run restaurant in Colorado. Mary Colacci used to invite the residents of Louisville to join the Colacci family for big Italian dinners on Sunday afternoons; she and her husband, Mike, finally opened their own restaurant in 1919. Their two sons worked there with their families; today the third through fifth generations of the Colacci family run the restaurant, which is a Louisville landmark.

Frank the Pizza King has been serving its Englewood neighborhood for more than fifty years.EXPAND
Frank the Pizza King has been serving its Englewood neighborhood for more than fifty years.
Courtesy of Frank the Pizza King

Frank the Pizza King
4701 South Broadway, Englewood
303-789-2279

Frank the Pizza King was founded on South Broadway in 1961 by Frank Krascek; today's it's run by Walter (Frank's son) and Maria Krascek. Since Frank is the pizza king, pizza dominates the menu, with a medium-thick crust and a generous slathering of red sauce. But homemade sausage sandwiches, Italian subs and other diner-style dishes are also available. 

Garlic lovers flock to the Saucy Noodle.EXPAND
Garlic lovers flock to the Saucy Noodle.
Danielle Lirette

The Saucy Noodle
727 South University Boulevard
303-733-6977

Opened in 1964, the Saucy Noodle celebrated fifty years in business under the same family ownership two years ago; Erin Markham took over operations in the 1990s from her grandfather, Sam Badis. Restaurant critic Gretchen Kurtz, in her review of the garlic-loving joint, noted that the "attitude, like the food itself, was nothing if not friendly, a personification of the family that has run the Saucy Noodle for all these years." Don't expect anything fancy — just the same meatballs, pastas, pizzas and family atmosphere that have been keeping Bonnie Brae neighbors coming back for decades.

Gaetano's has been through several ownership changes and remodels, but it still captures a piece of Denver's history.
Gaetano's has been through several ownership changes and remodels, but it still captures a piece of Denver's history.
Chris Utterback

Gaetano's
3760 Tejon Street
303-455-9852

Gaetano's underworld history, when the place was run by the Smaldone crime family back in the ’40s, is familiar to Denver natives, as is the overhaul by the Breckenridge-Wynkoop group, which purchased the place in 2006. There's still plenty of history left in the joint (although it's not so much a joint anymore), and it's back in independent hands, having been purchased by Ron Robinson in 2013. Today Gaetano's remains a great neighborhood spot with a swank Frank Sinatra vibe, and the sauce is a marked improvement from the days of the Smaldones.

The bar at Gennaro's, opposite the cozy dining room.
The bar at Gennaro's, opposite the cozy dining room.
Eric Gruneisen

Gennaro's Lounge
2598 South Broadway
303-722-1044

Gennaro's has been a low-key, red-sauce, neighborhood Italian joint for more than fifty years, with just two owners in that time. Separated from its companion bar by a bank of windows (you can also order off the menu in the bar), the dining room has just a few tables with red-checked cloths, as well as a view of the kitchen cooking up pizza and pasta. Hand-tossed pizzas and calzones big enough for two highlight a menu long on American-Italian classics like lasagna, baked ziti, and sausage and peppers.

Dino's is a West Colfax veteran.
Dino's is a West Colfax veteran.
Westword

Dino's Italian Food
10040 West Colfax Avenue, Lakewood
303-238-7393

Apparently 1961 was a good year for Italian restaurants; Dino's popped up that year on West Colfax Avenue and has been keeping the red sauce simmering ever since. The restaurant, founded by Dino DiPaolo and still run by his daughter, Judy Duren, gives Denver's western suburbs a taste of pizza, Italian sandwiches, baked lasagna and manicotti, as well as piles of pasta.

Use Current Location

Related Locations

miles
The Blue Parrot Restaurant
miles
The Saucy Noodle

727 S. University Blvd.
Denver, CO 80209

303-733-6977

www.saucynoodle.com

miles
Gaetano's Restaurant
miles
Gennaro's Lounge
miles
Dino's Italian Food

10040 W. Colfax Ave.
Lakewood, CO 80215

303-238-7393

miles
Frank the Pizza King

4701 S. Broadway
Englewood, CO 80113-6804

303-789-2279

www.frankthepizzaking.com


Sponsor Content

Newsletters

All-access pass to the top stories, events and offers around town.

  • Top Stories
    Send:

Newsletters

All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >