Elway winds up in the fourth position. Here's Pare's reasoning:
I know this will be blasphemy to some, but Elway was terrible in Super Bowl XXIV. His Denver Broncos got crushed by the San Francisco 49ers 55-10. Elway completed just 10 passes for 108 yards. He also has two interceptions and two fumbles. The Broncos were down 24 points at the half. Elway's two interceptions, on the team's first two possessions of the second half, killed any chance the Broncos had at a comeback.
Thanks for reminding me about three of the most painful hours of my life, Darren! And he does the same in the second slot, awarded to onetime Broncos signal-caller (and Ring of Fame inductee) Craig Morton:
Another struggling Broncos quarterback, Morton was shut down by the Cowboys in Super Bowl XII. Denver lost the game 27-10 and the quarterback position was the main reason why. Morton completed 4 of 15 attempts for 39 yards and four interceptions. Morton was eventually pulled from the game and replaced by Norris Weese.
Unfortunately for Morton, this would be his last shot at winning the Super Bowl; he'd previously come up on the short end of Super Bowl V while playing for the Dallas Cowboys. But as we all know, Elway led the Broncos to victory in Super Bowls XXXII and XXXIII, earning MVP honors before riding into a glorious orange sunset.
Sweet redemption! And if he can get the Broncos back to the pigskin promised land as an executive, we'll forget all about Super Bowl XXIV. I hope.
More from our Sports archive: "John Elway, Twitter all-pro -- and star of a new Denver Broncos reality show?"