The battle between My Brother's Bar and Brothers Bar & Grill is over. Attorneys for the two restaurants -- one the oldest continually operating saloon in the city, the other a link in a Wisconsin-based chain -- met with a magistrate last Friday and arrived at a deal.
Before it opened the massive sports bar at 1920 Market Street, in the building that had been the setting for Real World: Denver, MTV's long-running "reality" series, Brothers had filed a motion demanding that it be allowed to use the Brothers name in the Denver marketplace. But Jim Karagas, owner of My Brother's, was concerned another Brothers would result in confusion in the marketplace.
Exhibit A: Two weeks ago, when a John Hickenlooper fundraiser was held at Brothers, people kept walking into My Brother's to find the event.
The two sides managed to reach a confidential settlement, one that will allow Brothers to use the name "It's Brothers" in Denver, but also requires disclaimers of any connection to My Brother's in its advertising.
That means that Karagas, who's run My Brother's for forty years (and the space at 2376 15th Street had been a saloon for eighty years before that) won't get stuck in a courtroom for a lengthy trial -- a good thing. It also gives him more time to greet regulars at the door of My Brother's Bar, a place that's such an institution it doesn't even have a sign.
We Believe Local Journalism is Critical to the Life of a City
Engaging with our readers is essential to Westword's mission. Make a financial contribution or sign up for a newsletter, and help us keep telling Denver's stories with no paywalls.
Support Our Journalism
More from our Calhoun/Wake-Up Call archive: "Civic Center Park on a roll with daily mobile food trucks: Panic in noodle park!"