Just hit Nomelie Cupcakes at 19751 East Main Street in Parker. According to the website, the joint technically closes between 2 and 4 p.m. on weekdays -- and maybe I'm just being crazy here, but wouldn't you think that a cupcake maker (or at least a cupcake maker who actually wanted to make some money) would endeavor to stay open especially during those hours?
After all, 2 to 4 p.m. is prime cupcakin' time for parents picking up their kids from school. And do you know how I know that? Because I was there during those technically closed hours, trying to score a few cupcakes. I had to be let in through the locked front door -- and I was surrounded by moms and their squealing, sticky, sugar-deprived rug rats all trying to do the same thing.
Okay, maybe surrounded is a bit of an overstatement. But Nomelie is a really small space, and there were at least three or four other mom-and-kid(s) units crammed in there with me. And as I didn't want to have to fight my way to the door against those sorts of odds, I had to be rather discrete in my ordering. It appeared that stocks were running low (another quirk in Nomelie's schedule -- the joint closes entirely as soon as the goods are sold out), and some of those kids? They looked like biters.
We Believe Local Journalism is Critical to the Life of a City
Engaging with our readers is essential to Westword's mission. Make a financial contribution or sign up for a newsletter, and help us keep telling Denver's stories with no paywalls.
Support Our Journalism
I managed to make it out the door with two vanilla and two chocolate cupcakes (pictured above), and while I have been nothing but disappointed by every other cupcake shop I have visited in town since the trend of opening little neighborhood cupcake shops became a big thing, these were actually quite good. Granted, they were on the small side (four or five bites, tops, and on a bet, I imagine I could eat a whole one in just two), and not exactly cheap ($2.75 each, $3 for the specialty ones like the Amarena cherry and French chocolate on tap for Thursdays), but owner Selah Davenport really knows what she's doing when it comes to makin' cakes.
She uses nothing but the best ingredients as a base (real vanilla, French chocolate, fresh fruits and imported odds-and-ends like those Amarena cherries, which she gets from Bologna, Italy), and then bakes with the sort of restraint that's generally completely unknown in some of the less professional shops. The frosting isn't piled on too deep (as it is almost everywhere else -- done as mom-bait even if it tastes like nothing more than eating a bowl full of sugar), the flavors in the cakes themselves display a patissiere's subtlety, and the flavor combinations are genius. No Quadruple Chocolate Orgasms here. No weird combinations, or ginormous goofy things that look like clown wigs on top of tiny footstools. Instead, she does simple French chocolate cupcakes with peanut butter frosting, banana cupcakes with cream cheese frosting, and more. They taste like the kind of cupcakes your mom would make.
Provided, of course, your mom was a professional baker with access to a pantry stuffed with high-rent produce and imported ingredients.
Though Davenport's grand opening is still ten days off (it's officially May 16) and her soft open was just four days ago (May 2), the shop is already doing enough business that people are banging on her door during down time. My guess? It's only going to get busier from here...