The question of who won the election to represent District 4 on the Adams 12 Five Star school board now rests with the Colorado Supreme Court.
Candidate Rico Figueroa has appealed a district court judge's recent ruling that the District 4 seat should be declared vacant. The judge had ruled that since Figueroa's opponent, Amy Speers, earned two-thirds of the vote and Figueroa earned just a third, the voters "expressed a clear intent not to elect him."
Since Speers was declared ineligible to serve when it was discovered that she lives outside the District 4 boundary, Figueroa is seeking an opinion that, as the second-highest vote-getter, he won the election.
So far, he hasn't had much luck. Last month, Broomfield District Court Judge Chris Melonakis found against Figueroa. "The Court finds as a matter of fact and concludes as a matter of law that he was not legally elected to the office," Melonakis wrote in his order.
Instead, he wrote, "a vacancy exists in the position for Director District 4 to be filled as provided by law." In this case, that means that the current school board members would appoint someone to fill the District 4 seat.
Marijuana Deals Near You
Figueroa appealed Melonakis's ruling last week directly to the state Supreme Court -- as is the process when it comes to election disputes. His attorney, Mario Nicolais, says they're asking the high court to weigh in on whether votes for Speers should count as votes against Figueroa, as Melonakis suggested. Nicolais doesn't think they should.
"You determine who won by counting the number of votes for a candidate -- and for a qualified candidate, in particular," he says. "Amy Speers is not qualified to take office."
Speers refused to drop out of the race when election officials discovered that she no longer lived within the District 4 boundaries due to recent redistricting. Instead, she kept asking people to vote for her in order to send a message to the school board that the residents of Adams 12 supported non-conservative candidates such as herself.
We Believe Local Journalism is Critical to the Life of a City
Engaging with our readers is essential to Westword's mission. Make a financial contribution or sign up for a newsletter, and help us keep telling Denver's stories with no paywalls.
Support Our Journalism
Secretary of State Scott Gessler attempted to stop Speers's votes from being counted by issuing an emergency rule on Election Day that declared that ballots cast for unqualified candidates were invalid. But a Denver District Court judge found that Gessler's rule was unlawful after a group of eight voters sued Gessler. The final vote tally showed that Speers earned 24,169 votes and Figueroa earned 14,081.
Now it's up to the Colorado Supreme Court to determine whether Figueroa's votes were enough. In the meantime, Nicolais asked that Melonakis's ruling be put on hold -- a request that he says was granted. Which means that it could still be several months before the voters of Adams 12 know who, exactly, they elected.Follow me on Twitter @MelanieAsmar or e-mail me at email@example.com