A new poll intended to make a serious point about the nomination of a Supreme Court justice to fill the seat opened after the death of Antonin Scalia winds up making a hilarious one about Donald Trump and newly retired Denver Broncos quarterback Peyton Manning.
Turns out America trusts Manning to pick Scalia's replacement more than Trump — or plenty of other famous folks.
The survey, by Public Policy Polling, determined that most voters would prefer President Barack Obama to nominate a new justice before he leaves office instead of allowing one of the Republican candidates for president do so if they win the office in November.
Here's a synopsis of the main findings:
• Only 33% of voters trust Ted Cruz to nominate the new Supreme Court justice (57% don’t), only 31% trust Donald Trump to (62% don’t), and just 26% trust Marco Rubio to (61% don’t). Independent voters in particular have little faith in the GOP hopefuls to nominate a Supreme Court justice- 61% don’t trust Trump to, and 58% don’t trust either Cruz or Rubio to. One particularly brutal finding for Rubio on this poll is that even among Republicans there are more (45%) who don’t trust him to make that appointment than do (41%) trust him.
• Reflecting what other national polling has found, 56% of voters in the country want the vacant seat on the Supreme Court seat to be filled this year by a nominee of President Obama’s, to only 40% of voters who think the seat should remain vacant for the next year. That includes 53/41 support from independents for filling the seat this year. Voters especially think that the Senate should at least see who President Obama puts forward before making a decision- 66% think Obama’s nominee should be given a chance to only 25% who believe the Senate should just refuse to confirm someone no matter who it is. Even Republican voters, 53/37, think the Senate should be open to Obama’s nominee rather than reflexively dismissive.
• This continues to look like an issue that has the potential to hurt Senate Republicans nationally this year. By a 19 point margin voters say they’re less likely to vote for a Senator who refuses to consider a nominee to the Supreme Court this year, with only 31% saying they’re more likely to vote for someone who takes that stance compared to 50% who say they’re less likely to. Independents would vote against a Senator with that position by a 16 point spread. This issue is just reinforcing the already awful brand of Senate Republicans nationally. Just 10% of voters in the country approve of the job Mitch McConnell is doing, to 59% who disapprove. His unpopularity is a liability for members of his caucus hoping to be reelected this year, and the approach he’s taking on this issue is just making the problem worse.
As a bonus, the polling service sought out a way to illustrate just how little faith there is in Trump on this subject — and its method of doing so was to compare him to a number of famous folks or figures.
Included among them was Manning, who kicked the Donald's ass. We've included the complete poll results below, but here's a graphic showing a head to head match-up, in which Peyton bests Trump by a 45-35 percent margin.
Not every celebrity did as well.
For instance, respondents trusted Trump slightly more than Will Smith....
...and the best Taylor Swift could do was a tie.
In addition, Manning squashed Mickey Mouse (as did Trump).
Still, Manning wasn't invincible. He couldn't quite top Tom Hanks.
Call if a Supreme victory for Hanks, whose film Forrest Gump Manning referenced at his retirement press conference.
Here's the aforementioned results document, followed by a bonus — an Oreo commercial from 2009 in which Trump and Peyton (along with his brother, Eli, and Saturday Night Live Trump imitator Darrell Hammond) appear together.
We Believe Local Journalism is Critical to the Life of a City
Engaging with our readers is essential to Westword's mission. Make a financial contribution or sign up for a newsletter, and help us keep telling Denver's stories with no paywalls.