As we've reported, the main players in this tragedy were Stephen Futrell and Jeremy Garcia. According to an arrest affidavit accessible below, Futrell, nicknamed "Magic," shot Garcia because he didn't like the way the latter man shook his shoulders.
The incident took place just after midnight on September 13, 2015 — and police quickly determined that surveillance video had caught images of Garcia and his suspected killer both inside and outside the club.
Later that morning, investigators quizzed a source whose identity is protected in the police report. That person said Futrell had been coming into the bar for about two months, usually on Fridays and Saturdays — and he introduced himself as "Magic." For his part, Garcia had been a regular for a month or so.
The victim came up behind Magic, grabbed Magic by the shoulders and shook Magic. This upset Magic and Magic told the victim, "You don't know me like that!" The victim told Magic, "We can settle this right now!" Magic told the victim "Settle what?" [Deleted] told Magic and the victim to stop arguing and directed each of them to opposite sides of the bar.Futrell went outside a short time later, presumably to smoke a cigarette. After that, Garcia headed outside, too — and within minutes, a woman ran into the club to announce that someone had been shot.
How did the cops find Futrell? Turns out he'd given his phone number to the unnamed source a couple of weeks earlier — and one of his aliases was "Mr. Magic."
His sentence: 35 years in prison.
The slaying at PT's II was hardly the only crime to have taken place at businesses once referred to by the euphemism "gentleman's club." In January, we counted at least eight killings or attacks at Colorado strip clubs over the previous six years. But the combination of incidents at the venue, including a New Year's Eve 2015 fire, resulted in a reputation exemplified by the following online review, posted shortly before it closed: "Went out to the parking lot and heard a gun go off so I had to drop to the ground while some guy bled out to death 15 feet away. DONT GO! Trashy area and SKETCHY people."
The purchase of PT's II is expected to be approved this fall. Click to read the Stephen Futrell arrest affidavit.