William Costello, accused serial rapist, linked to two more crimes but bond lowered

Late last month, we told you about William Costello, charged with being a serial rapist after his DNA scored strikes on three previous sex assaults; see our original coverage below. Since then, he's been linked to two more crimes, yet his bond was actually lowered -- and he's since been released, prompting frustration for the Denver District Attorney's Office. Details below.

As we reported, Costello was arrested this past June for allegedly attacking a man at a grocery store who asked if he'd sign a petition. Afterward, a DNA sample was taken and run through the system -- and it registered three matches.

The first took place in March 2008 and involved a thirteen-year-old girl who a man had violated in a vehicle also occupied by a two year old in a car seat. The second dated to August 2010, when a 22-year-old woman was forced to perform oral sex on a man who claimed to be a police officer. And the third, dating back to September 2011, involved a 49-year-old victim groped and violated by an attacker who also claimed to be a cop.

In the wake of Costello's arrest, the Denver Post learned that he was a successful real estate broker with a reputation as a good father and ties to a number of powerful and influential Democrats in the state, including former Colorado Governor Dick Lamm.

Did powerful pals help Costello gain his freedom, at least temporarily? Well, last week, according to Denver DA's office spokeswoman Lynn Kimbrough, corresponding via e-mail, his bond was lowered from $200,000 to $150,000 despite objections from the prosecutor on the case. He subsequently paid this amount and was released.

Kimbrough also confirms that "two other people came forward with information" that connects him to another pair of cases, bringing the total in which he's suspected to five.

Costello's next court appearance will be a preliminary hearing slated for 8:30 a.m. on January 30. In the meantime, though, he's no longer behind bars.

Here's a larger look at Costello's booking photo, followed by our previous coverage, including his arrest affidavit.

Continue to read our previous coverage about William Costello. Original post, 8:58 a.m. November 20: When William Costello was arrested in June, for allegedly breaking the hip of an elderly man, he seemed like little more than a combustible creep. But after a DNA test run on him under a provision of Katie's Law scored several hits, the Denver District Attorney's Office has concluded that Costello is something more -- a serial rapist. Documents and the startling details below.

On June 30, according to the first in a series of arrest affidavits on view below, a Denver Police rep was called to the King Soopers at 2810 Quebec Street on an assault report. There, the officer learned that an elderly man had been standing near the door collecting signatures for a pro-life petition. When he asked a customer to sign the sheet on his clipboard, the man, later identified as Costello, 47, rejected this entreaty because of his belief in abortion. However, Costello is also said to have shouted several obscenities -- and when the petition collector told him he could "still go to heaven," he supposedly became even more exorcised, grabbing the clipboard in order to throw it to the ground and pushing him off his bike.

The fall broke the man's hip.

At that point, Costello, whose mug shot has not yet been released, fled the scene -- but a witness eyeballed his license plate, allowing the cops to track him down. When confronted, Costello is quoted as claiming that while angry words had been exchanged, he'd only grabbed the clipboard to prevent himself from being struck by it and denied that he'd given the man a shove. Instead, he insisted that the man had toppled of his own accord.

The officer didn't buy this explanation and arrested Costello on suspicion of second-degree assault of an at-risk adult.

The bust triggered the collection of a DNA sample -- and when personnel checked it against previously collected data, matches were reportedly found in a three separate cases.

The first incident took place in March 2008 and involved a thirteen-year-old girl who lived at the Denver Children's Home. She told an officer that she'd become upset with the personnel at the facility and had decided to run away. Shortly after reaching the intersection of East 16th Avenue and North Bellaire Street, she was approached by a dark blue, four-door sedan driven by a five-feet-ten-inch, 160 pound white male with short brown hair and blue eyes.

The man, who wore a black baseball cap, a red T-shirt and green shorts, was accompanied by a two-year-old boy in the back of the vehicle. He told the girl his name was Will, and asked if she wanted to hang out. She agreed and climbed into the vehicle, at which point he began to touch and penetrate her genitals. This went on for five minutes or so, after which the man told her he'd ejaculated.

He then told her he wanted to do it again, and she complied, reportedly because she feared for her safety -- and she had every reason to be afraid. Before he let her go, she said he opened his trunk and pulled out a black, semi-automatic handgun.

Continue to read more about the allegations against reputed serial rapist William Costello. Afterward, an examination was conducted, and semen was found in the girl's panties -- presumably the source of the DNA that matched the sample taken from Costello after the June King Soopers assault.

For the second case, skip forward to August 2010, when a Denver Police officer was dispatched to 14400 East Colfax to meet with an Aurora cop with a 22-year-old woman identified as a sex-assault victim.

The woman said she'd been near the intersection of East Colfax and North Krameria Street when she was approached by a male in a black Mercedes. At that point, she asked him to take her through the drive-thru of a nearby Del Taco to get some food, since the indoor seating area was closed.

Once in the vehicle, the man drove southbound and began to fondle her breast. She asked him if he was a police officer, and he initially told her no, but the narrative quotes him as changing his tune shortly thereafter; he claimed he was "crooked" and told her she could "make some money."

This offer didn't appeal to the woman, who reportedly asked for him to take her back to where he'd picked her up. Instead, he asked what are characterized as "sexually explicit questions" before pulling over, sticking his hand down her pants and trying to penetrate her vagina. He then is accused of pulling his pants down, putting on a condom, grabbing the woman by the neck and hair and forcing her to give him oral sex. Shortly thereafter, the man is said to have forced the woman to remove her clothes and began raping her. The woman screamed and cried, especially after the condom broke, but the man continued with the sex act while choking her. He then dropped her off at a 7-Eleven next to the Del Taco, at which point she contacted police.

The description of the suspect this time around was a bit different from the 2008 case, but with some similarities: a white male in the five-seven range, with a shaved head and no facial hair. He was wearing a black baseball cap, a gray T-shirt and blue jeans. However, the DNA collected from vaginal and abdomen swabs also scored a strike with Costello.

Continue to read more about the allegations against reputed serial rapist William Costello. Case number three took place on September 28, 2011. The arrest report quotes the 49-year-old victim as saying that she was waiting for a bus at West 32nd Avenue and North Federal Boulevard when a blue Mercedes pulled up with the passenger window down. The man inside told the woman he was a police officer; when he ordered her into the car, she reluctantly complied. They then drove to an area near West 45th Avenue and North Irving Street, where the suspect -- a bald white male of medium build wearing a baseball cap, a blue shirt and blue jeans -- exposed his penis and told her she either needed to have sex with him or she'd be going to jail.

The woman said she'd prefer the latter, but she wasn't given the choice. The affidavit notes that the man grabbed her by the back of the head and tried to force her to orally service him. She responded by fighting him off as best she could, but he overpowered her, held her down, licked her breasts, neck and lips and digitally penetrated her anus. At that point, she told him she'd provide him with oral sex, but when he climbed back into the driver's seat, she jumped out of the car, ran to a nearby home with a porch light and began asking for those inside to call the police. At that point, the suspect drove away.

Again, a rape kit was used, and again, male DNA was found on a swab that matched with Costello's.

The result of these discoveries? Costello has been charged with two counts of second-degree kidnapping, two counts of sexual assault on a child, three counts of sexual assault and two counts of impersonating a peace officer. He's being held on $200,000 and is scheduled to make his first court appearance at 9:30 a.m. today.

Look below to see a CBS4 report about Costello, as well as the aforementioned affidavits.

William Costello Arrest Affidavits

More from our Schmuck of the Week archive: "Robert Bruce, serial rapist and schmuck, has bride asking, Who the [Bleep] Did I Marry?"

We use cookies to collect and analyze information on site performance and usage, and to enhance and customize content and advertisements. By clicking 'X' or continuing to use the site, you agree to allow cookies to be placed. To find out more, visit our cookies policy and our privacy policy.


All-access pass to the top stories, events and offers around town.

  • Top Stories


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >