Known as “The Unauthorized Harry Experience,” Jefferson Turner and Daniel Clarkson initially created the act as a ten-minute sketch for the release of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, the penultimate book, in 2005. The show has been in near-constant rotation since, touring around the world.
"We were thinking naively that we would be performing for about 100 people,” Turner says. There were closer to 1,200, and the comedians performed multiple times to different sections of the line.
“We never experienced anything like it,” Turner adds, comparing it to 1960s Beatlemania. Turner had read all five of the existing Harry Potter books in the weeks before their performance. He says he “just adored them” and, “if anything, they’re page-turners.”
Turner describes Potted Potter as "your classic straight-man funny act." He often plays the straight man to Clarkson's oblivious buffoon. Eventually, however, the audience finds out that it’s just “two fools trying to retell the story,” Turner clarifies. “And we do manage it, though lots is planned to go wrong.”
The course of the show encompasses seven books, 360 characters, one fire-breathing dragon and one Quidditch match, the Potted Potter website boasts. There are also references to pop culture and literature, and simple slapstick that anyone can enjoy.

Co-creator Jefferson Turner (left) says that "proper Potter heads love the show."
StarVox Entertainment
“We were terrified when we first brought it out to the States,” Turner says, citing a fear that the British jokes wouldn’t land. But they opened in New York City, and “the audience got the humor immediately.”
In fact, they only need change certain cultural references to suit different global audiences. Even so, Potted Potter is constantly evolving. Turner says he and Clarkson have performed it over 2,000 times, so it’s more fun for them to change up the sequence.
Their favorite moments are when they deliver jokes that make all ages in the audience laugh, in part because they hope their show will encourage children to love the theater. “When you’re a kid, there’s something magical about laughing as the same joke as your mom or dad,” Turner says.
Much of the success of the comedy show is credited to the long-lasting appeal of Harry Potter, Turner continues. They’ve done a few other spinoffs such as Potted Pirates, Potted Sherlock and Potted Panto, but none has had quite the same reaction.
“The books are enduring,” he says, noting that “proper Potter heads love the show."
But even audience members with no prior knowledge of the Potter canon should be able to come and join in the laughter.
Potted Potter is one of four Newman Center Presents performances this January. Also on the roster are Kronos Quartet (Wednesday, January 12), Dance Theatre of Harlem (Friday, January 14, and Saturday, January 15) and Compagnie Hervé Koubi (Saturday, January 29).
Potted Potter, Tuesday, January 4, to Sunday, January 9, Newman Center for the Performing Arts, 2344 East Iliff Avenue. Tickets are $36.99.