Booking photos of Billy Scott and Leslie Barrett.EXPAND
Booking photos of Billy Scott and Leslie Barrett.
Arvada Police Department

Like the Worst Dog the Bounty Hunter Episode Ever: Inside Troy Pitman Murder

Update: In March 2015, we told you about the killing of 44-year-old Troy Pitman at his home on Gray Street in Arvada; our previous coverage has been incorporated in this post.

Two people — Leslie Barrett and Billy Scott — were subsequently arrested on suspicion of committing homicide.

In the immediate aftermath of the incident, Arvada police didn't offer many details about what had taken place and why Barrett and Scott had been fitted with cuffs.

But now, following Barrett's guilty plea and Scott's conviction for first-degree murder and more, the details have been made public — and it turns out the killing came as the result of a bail-bond issue that turned into the sort of episode Dog the Bounty Hunter never aired.

The scene of the crime.
The scene of the crime.
7News via YouTube

On March 19 of last year, according to the First Judicial District DA's office, Scott and Barrett went to Pitman's home over what's characterized as "a bail-bond issue."

Specifically, Pitman had put up collateral for an unnamed woman who hadn't turned up at a scheduled court date.

Barrett was a licensed bail-bond agent, and she was in business with Scott, her boyfriend, in Scott Free Bail Bonds, Inc. — although the firm hadn't been operating for long.

Indeed, Barrett's LinkedIn page, which is still online at this writing, dates her work as a "Licensed Surety Agent" as beginning in February 2015, the previous month.

Scott's role that day was "to act as protection," the DA's office notes.

Before long, however, the situation got out of hand.

A closer look at the house where the homicide took place.
A closer look at the house where the homicide took place.
7News via YouTube

Upon their arrival at the house, witnesses said, Barrett and Scott saw that the garage was open and that Pitman was inside along with his brother.

At that point, the DA's office maintains, "Scott burst into the garage, uninvited, and attacked Mr. Pitman."

Pitman's brother responded by trying to pull Scott off the man he'd targeted.

That's when Barrett produced a gun — at which point things got complicated.

Prosecutors say Scott ran behind Barrett, put his arms around her and his hands over hers, which were on the gun.

And then he pulled the trigger.

The bullet struck Pitman in the back, killing him.

Investigators at the scene.
Investigators at the scene.
7News via YouTube

This past February, Barrett pleaded guilty to accessory to murder and menacing.

Rather than entering a plea of his own, Scott went to trial, and earlier this month, a jury found him guilty of first-degree murder, first-degree murder after deliberation, three counts of burglary, four violent crime counts and menacing with a deadly weapon.

This decision didn't end Scott's trip through the court system. He was charged as a habitual criminal, necessitating another trial to determine the length of time he'll be put away.

And bail won't be an option.

We use cookies to collect and analyze information on site performance and usage, and to enhance and customize content and advertisements. By clicking 'X' or continuing to use the site, you agree to allow cookies to be placed. To find out more, visit our cookies policy and our privacy policy.


All-access pass to the top stories, events and offers around town.

  • Top Stories


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >