Best Italian Restaurant
Santino's on Downing
The menu says that “only grandma could make it better,” but we don’t see how even she could improve on the food at Santino’s on Downing. Chef/owner Santino “Sonny” Rando’s marinara, for example, is the red sauce of dreams, slow-simmered until the fresh, herb-enhanced tomatoes cook down into a thick, rich liquid. It’s just the right consistency for ladling over Rando’s cheese-packed shells; throw in a few of his wickedly salty, oil-slicked, garlic-packed rolls and a glass of top-shelf Italian wine from his well-chosen list and you have the most comforting of Italian meals. But don’t think Rando can’t see beyond red: Other items on the menu offer a grand tour of his prowess with sauces, from mushroom-imbued creams to Sicilian-inspired lemon-based dreams. Forget grandma’s house — it’s to Santino’s we go for impressive Italian fare in an intimate, inviting setting.