The 5 Best Dishes Invented in Colorado | Westword
Navigation

The Five Best Dishes Invented in Colorado

From Mexican hamburgers to root beer floats, celebrate the state's 147th birthday by digging into these Colorado originals.
The Mexican hamburger was originally invented at Joe's Buffet on Santa Fe.
The Mexican hamburger was originally invented at Joe's Buffet on Santa Fe. Mark Antonation

Local News is Vital to Our Community

When you support our community-rooted newsroom, you enable all of us to be better informed, connected, and empowered during this important election year. Give now and help us raise $12,000 by June 7.

Support local journalism

$0
$12,000
$500
Share this:
Happy Colorado Day! On August 1, we're celebrating a state full of natural beauty as well as many man-made marvels. This state's culinary creativity has cooked up everything from Jolly Rancher candies to Chipotle burritos; Coors beer and some of the country's best craft brews run through our history.

Colorado is also where many chains got their start, from Chitpotle (whose first spot, on East Evans, opened exactly thirty years ago), to Qdoba, Noodles & Company and Quiznos, whose original location in Cap Hill finally closed earlier this year.

Here, in honor of the state's 147th birthday, we've reheated our list of five favorite Colorado food inventions:
click to enlarge close up peanut butter, jelly and bacon
Yes, Elvis ate this.
YouTube

Fool's Gold Loaf

In the 2014 film What If, two twenty-something hipsters in Toronto start talking about a sandwich that was created in Denver almost forty years ago, when the Colorado Mine Company was the hottest restaurant in Glendale, beloved by athletes, cops...and Elvis. Nick Andurlakis, who was in the restaurant's kitchen one night when the King came through the back door, in town for a concert and hungry, later opened Nick's Cafe at 777 1/2 Simms Street in Lakewood, where he served a version of the Fool's Gold sandwich until Nick's closed in March 2022.

If you want to re-create this indelicate delicacy at home, it's basically a peanut butter and jelly sandwich with bacon, made with two tablespoons of margarine, one loaf of French bread, one pound of bacon, one jar of peanut butter and one jar of grape jelly. You take the bread, bathe it in butter on all sides, bake it, gut it and then fill the inside with peanut butter and jelly — and bacon, sans grease, which you absorb by placing it between two paper towels.

Root Beer Float

There are several stories about the invention of the root beer float floating around, but most people credit Frank Wisner with the creation of the popular ice cream drink. He was looking out of his window at Colorado's Cow Mountain and decided that the snow on top looked like ice cream floating in a dark drink. Yes, that's all it took: The next day, he dropped a scoop of ice cream in some root beer, and the famous concoction was born.

Shredded Wheat

As you start your morning right with a bowl of shredded wheat, you can thank Henry Perkins. He's the Denver man who developed a method of processing wheat into strips, which made the cereal possible. 
a stone marker
The Humpty-Dumpty is gone, but its burger achievement lives on.
Mark Antonation

Cheeseburger

Although numerous cooks have claimed credit for being the first to put cheese on a burger, Louis Ballast was awarded the "cheeseburger" trademark in 1935. Today a monument stands at 2755 Speer Boulevard, where he once flipped burgers — and then added cheese — at his Humpty-Dumpty Drive-In. While that location is now home to a KeyBank and any taste of Ballast's burgers is long-gone, Denver does have a lot of standouts in the category. Check out our list of the ten best burgers in the city, as well as our favorite old-school burger joints
a yellow building next to a purple building
Celebrate the state with a Mexican hamburger at Chubby's.
Danielle Lirette

Mexican Hamburger

You can find a Mexican hamburger on the menu of just about every Mexican restaurant in Denver — and a lot of restaurants where the dish is the kitchen's only claim to anything Mexican. But as it turns out, there's nothing Mexican to this hamburger: It was invented at Joe's Buffet, a classic dive on Santa Fe Drive in the late ’60s, and from there the dish spread across town. Gustavo Arellano, author of Ask a Mexican, wrote the book on Mexican food in this country — Taco USA: How Mexican Food Conquered America — and proclaimed Denver's Mexican hamburger "the Holy Grail of Mexican-American cookery," lauding its "cheesy, mixed-up glory." 

Here's his description of the dish from Taco USA:
Brace yourselves, folks: underneath that Syracuse Orangeman-hued goop lies the structure of a burrito—a flour tortilla containing refried beans, your choice of meat, and a grilled hamburger patty, almost extant in shape. This version is smothered, which means Colorado's classic take on green chile (flecked with pork, and prepared as a gravy) drowns the burrito burger with its viscous, spicy glory. The flour tortilla itself is cooked well until it becomes firm, until you can slice off a chunk and it won't flop around on your fork as it enters your mouth.

I've had puffy tacos in San Antonio, glorious bowls of the green in Albuquerque, the Mexican hot dog of El Paso, and gargantuan Mission burritos in San Francisco, but the Mexican hamburger—found only in Denver, much to the surprise of the Mile High City's residents, who always thought their dish, like the Broncos, had a national reach—is the dish that best personifies the Mexican-American experience. The tortilla is wholly indigenous; its flour rendition, the legacy of Spain. The focus on green chile places it firmly in the Southwest; its gravy presentation, the legacy of Tex-Mex. The hamburger patty, of course, is wholly American—but even that has a German past. The combination of all is pure rascuache. And the taste? Heavy, thick, yet the Mexican hamburger at its best retains all the flavors of its distinct parts. I only ate half of this, having to stop myself because I had just eaten a sandwich, a taco, and another burrito.

Let the Baylessistas scream—this is a dish as Mexican as the Templo Mayor, as American as the Washington Monument, as Chicano as SanTana. And few dishes have as juicy a back story: its most-famous seller is Chubby's, a legendary chain run by matriarch Stella Cordova until she was nearing the century mark. But the one above comes from Bubba Chino's, run by her grandson Leonard, who is unfortunately strained from most of his relatives, who ripped off their abuelita's name before she had even passed on, much to Stella's disapproval.

Ah, Mexicans, always fighting among ourselves—but there you have it, folks: the Mexican hamburger, the meal of mestizaje at its tastiest.
Although Joe's Buffet closed decades ago (the space is currently vacant) and Stella Cordova has passed on, the original Chubby's still serves one of Denver's best Mexican hamburgers...even if it's doing so from a much tidier building that occupies what had been the parking lot.
 
Have one on Colorado Day!

This story has been updated from the original 2014 version.
BEFORE YOU GO...
Can you help us continue to share our stories? Since the beginning, Westword has been defined as the free, independent voice of Denver — and we'd like to keep it that way. Our members allow us to continue offering readers access to our incisive coverage of local news, food, and culture with no paywalls.