Cassandra Stiltner
Audio By Carbonatix
‘Tis the season…for tax seizures. On the heels of venue Your Mom’s House being seized for unpaid taxes, the doors are now locked at another local business for the same reason — though it’s pushing back.
If you’re hoping to pick up some holiday cookies for Christmas, Hanukkah or New Year’s, don’t plan on getting them from Maggie & Molly’s Sweet Life bakery. According to a message posted to the store’s website, it’s been shut down by the city over a tax dispute.
“The City of Denver made a complete dick move to renege on a tax payment plan they offered that provided a January 20 due date,” reads the defiant message in all caps. “We are officially over and inconsolable about the betrayal.”
The bakery, which began as an online business in 2005, opened its brick-and-mortar location on Sixth Avenue in 2010, next to the Truffle Cheese Shop (which incidentally also closed earlier this year after being seized for unpaid taxes). It offers a range of cakes, pies, pastries, cookies, and cupcakes, available both as online pickup orders or in-store purchases. It was also a 2013 Best of Denver winner for its coffee cake.
Will you step up to support Westword this year?
At Westword, we’re small and scrappy — and we make the most of every dollar from our supporters. Right now, we’re $20,500 away from reaching our December 31 goal of $50,000. If you’ve ever learned something new, stayed informed, or felt more connected because of Westword, now’s the time to give back.
The bakery is known for accommodating special requests and personalized orders for occasions such as wedding cakes, parties, and, of course, holiday seasonal fare. That includes vibrantly decorated Christmas sugar cookie trays and gingerbread cookies, a Hanukkah sugar cookie decorating kit, and “confetti cookies” and a “clock strikes midnight” cake for New Year’s.
Cassandra Stiltner
That the store was forced to close during Hanukkah and just a week before Christmas Eve, not to mention the coming New Year’s Eve celebrations, is likely to disrupt at least some customers’ festive plans.
“We are working through refunds and will fulfill as many holiday orders as we can,” reads the website message. “Since we now have our customer orders, you’ll be notified.”
As the website message indicates, owner Mary Lovett is not one to hold back her opinions. She’s been a go-to source for media, offering comments on issues affecting restaurants and food businesses, such as the need to raise menu prices to cover Denver’s minimum wage increases (which she supported) and the federal ban on artificial dyes (which she does not).
According to the warrant issued by the City of Denver Department of Finance, the bakery owed over $30,000 in unpaid sales tax dating back to December 2023. “When businesses charge customers sales tax but then do not submit that sales tax to the city, the city is responsible for becoming involved,” the department said in a statement to Westword. “We try to work with taxpayers, often for significant periods of time, to ensure they can continue to operate. Warrants are only issued after repeated attempts to collect taxes from the business fall short (in this case, since December 2023). We want to see every business in Denver succeed, and warrants are an absolute last resort.”
We’ve reached out to Lovett for comment, and will update this story as we learn more.
